Tata Steel Chess: "Tomorrow is the wedding night"
1/28/2018 – Shakhriyar Mamedyarov made a quick draw with Gawain Jones in under 30 minutes. That gave both Anish Giri and Magnus Carlsen an opening to grab the lead with a win, heading into the final round on Sunday. In the Challangers, Vidit got a critical win with black against Girya, and takes a half point edge into round thirteen. Analysis and commentary by GM Daniel Fernandez | Photo: Alina l'Ami Tata Steel Chess on Facebook
Find the right combination! ChessBase 15 program + new Mega Database 2019 with 7.6 million games and more than 70,000 master analyses. Plus ChessBase Magazine (DVD + magazine) and CB Premium membership for 1 year!
Giri and Carlsen tied
Anish Giri is having his best performance in Tata Steel Chess ever, and faces one final test on Sunday in round thirteen. He joked in his post-game interview after round eleven that talk of a tiebreak was premature, "like marrying and skipping your wedding night", but now it looks like a real possibility. Both players will have black. Mamedyarov gets white, but facing an in-form Anand is not exactly easy.
Impressions from Round 12
Round twelve in Wijk aan Zee | Tata Steel Chess on YouTube
Standings after twelve rounds
The round kicked off with a wimper as co-leader Shakhriyar Mamedyarov played a 12 move draw with Gawain Jones. The pair began repeating moves before the game left opening theory. Mamedyarov argued that avoiding a repetition would leave him worse, and blamed Jones for not trying harder with white. Jones had been surprised by Mamedyarov's opening choice and considered a draw versus the current world number two a fine result, so he saw no reason to play on. Here's the explanation from both players immediately after the game.
Mamedyarov explains his choice to repeat | Tata Steel Chess on YouTube
Jones was satisfied to get a draw by any means | Tata Steel Chess on YouTube
Although not an "agreed" draw — which would be simply limited by recourse to some flavor of Sofia-Corsica rules — this kind of result is disappointing to spectators, and tournament rules generally should have incentives aimed at eliminating the practice of a quick repetion of moves. That could include, for instance, a "fighting prize", as implemented in Australia's Doeberl Cup, for which a player is only eligable in the absence of short draws, or a provision to replay a drawn game with a rapid time control, as tried successfully by the Zurich Chess Challenge.
Traditionally the tournament in Wijk aan Zee has never resorted to such measures, in part because with seven games per round, having some of them end unspectacularly is not a public relations disaster, if there are other interesting games to follow. Still, to see such a game from a co-leader in the penultimate round is remarkable. Most of the players asked about the incident after the round placed the blame on Mamedyarov, arguing that he should have tried to continue the game, relying on his big rating advantave over Jones of over 160 Elo points.
From the standpoint of tournament strategy, Mamedyarov has few chances to win. Even if he beats Anand in the last round, it's likely that Carlsen and Giri will at least draw, and a three-way tie would leave Mamedyarov out of the tiebreak, since he lost to Giri in round eight. The first criteria is "direct encounter". The same applies to Kramnik — even if he manages to beat Adhiban with black in round thirteen, and by some miracle Carlsen and Giri both lose, Kramnik's loss to Giri would prevent him from contending a tiebreak.
Analysis and comments by GM Daniel Fernandez
Viswanathan Anand ½-½ Wesley So
Anand-So was an interesting theoretical dispute in an opening the White player knows a thing or two about. There were probably one or two chances to retain a slight edge, and the jury is still out on the interesting 21.b4!? which would definitely have provoked flashbacks in the Black player. That being said, once Black had equalised there was nothing really left of the game.
The Open Ruy Lopez gives Black free piece play and chances for the initiative. This sharp and interesting variation has been used by many of the all-time greats, including Anand, Kortschnoi, Botvinnik, Keres, Euwe, Fine and Reshevsky and this is by no means an exhaustive list. White will argue that Black loosens his position in the Open Variation, but if Black takes the time and trouble to learn the ideas and tactical themes that underpin this line, he has every chance to win the game. This will be especially interesting to the club player as it doubtless has been to the grandmasters mentioned above.
Wesley So has had fine results, but never challenged for the top spots | Photo: Alina l'Ami © 2018 Tata Steel
Hou Yifan ½-½ Wei Yi
Hou-Wei was also a psychologically interesting game in that the World Champion adapted an idea used against her in the very first round and nearly executed it even better. She definitely had a large advantage in a queen and single rook 'endgame', though the advantage dissipated when she accidentally opened a few routes for Black's eventual counterplay.
A World champion's guide to the Petroff
The great popularity of the Petroff Defence at the highest level has attracted general attention as strong players employ this opening with great success and with both colours. Unfortunately, the opinion of the Petroff as a sterile drawish opening seems to be firmly implanted in many minds. The author tries to dispel these myths and examines the most popular lines and provides a large number of ideas that will enable you to play Petroff successfully, with either colour.
Judit Polgar arrived on Saturday as a special guest of the tournament | Photo: Alina l'Ami © 2018 Tata Steel
Magnus Carlsen 1-0 Maxim Matlakov
Carlsen-Matlakov was a 'typical Carlsen game' in that, without seeming to have any special preparation, the World Champion obtained an endgame position where his opponent had to play precisely to either keep a pawn or obtain compensation for it, and ended up doing neither. While the resulting position could maybe still have been held, in practice that was simply never going to happen.
— Willum Morsch (@WillumTM) January 27, 2018
Sicilian Paulsen Powerbook 2016
In our Powerbook we have brought together all games with the ECO codes B40-B49. Added to 62 000 selected master games from both Mega and correspondence chess there 122 000 high class games from the engine room on playchess.com.
Vladimir Kramnik 1-0 Fabiano Caruana
Kramnik-Caruana was another 'concept game', just like the one Kramnik himself lost in the previous round to Karjakin- straight out of the opening White goes for the bishop pair, gains an edge, cashes in for a pawn and then converts. An idle curiosity- given the reputations of the two players, when was the last time Kramnik and Carlsen both played 1.e4 in the same round of an event?
Play the Exchange Variation against the Caro-Kann
The Exchange Variation (1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5 cxd5 4.Bd3) is a simple and easy to learn answer to the Caro-Kann. By clarifying the central tension White gives himself a clear plan of attack using the half open e-file and the e5 square. This is far from easy for Black to meet as Bobby Fischer, Jan Timman, Walter Browne and other leading Grandmasters have demonstrated in their games. Black too has his resources but he needs to know what he's doing.
Anish Giri 1-0 Baskaran Adhiban
In Giri-Adhiban, Black's opening experimentation came unstuck, slowly at first but then increasingly rapidly. Having tried to do this kind of thing many times myself I can empathise completely, and while there are some concrete suggestions for where Black could plug holes if future players really do want to do this, the fact of today's game was that White simply played better. The finish was especially convincing.
The Sniper is a universal opening framework which can be played against all main first white moves — 1.e4, 1.d4, 1.c4, 1.f4 and 1.Nf3. Black plays 1...g6, 2...Bg7 and 3...c5 against practically anything!
Round-up show with Lawrence Trent
Commentary by GM Eric Hansen and GM Jan Smeets | Tata Steel Chess YouTube
Challengers
Vidit broke the tie with Korobov by winnng with black and is now the heavy favourite to qualify to the masters.
See: Tata Steel Challengers: Vidit has the edge
Standings after twelve rounds
All games
Links
- Official site
- Round 11: Tied trio
- Round 10: And then there were three (again)
- Round 9: Giri makes his move
- Round 8: A three horse race
- Round 7: Carlsen gets it going
- Round 6: Reversals of fortune
- Round 5: 'Shak' joins Anand, Anish
- Round 4: Kramnik shines
- Round 3: Anand ups the ante
- Round 2: Giri grabs early lead
- Round 1: And they're off!
- Wijk aan Zee turns 80 — and other stats
- On the bucket list: Wijk aan Zee
- Tata Steel Chess 2018 field complete
Discussion and Feedback
Join the public discussion or submit your feedback to the editors
We had one of the most exciting tournament I can remember and some people are still complaining about ONE single short draw ?
'Sofia' rule was mentioned. Along with a 30 or 40 minimum for moves per player, logic dictates that a needed corollary is: Any player who causes the third occurrence of a position, before the Sofia minimum is reached, can be declared the loser by his opponent. Else you risk fiascoes like L.McShaneH.Nakamura 2015 in Las Vegas at the Millionaire Chess 2 tournament, where Organizer Maurice Ashley and Nakamura argued for ninety seven minutes before Ashley gave in an allowed the players to have their draw after White's ninth move Bc1.
I find GM Fernandez's comment about Anand having invented the Open Spanish a bit odd... Korchnoi played it consistently throughout his two WCh matches against Karpov, with fairly decent results.
Here too (as in the German version): Carlsen's possible quick win after 51. ... Kh4 is not mentioned at all (though discussed in the live broadcast and on twitter).
I am completely with Gawain Jones on this. Mamedyarov is much higher rated and was in a situation where he had the opportunity to try to win the tournament. So it was his responsibility to create an interesting game. The Petroff was a bad choice so he has only himself to blame for the outcome. Mamedyarov's long moan in the interview trying to blame Jones for the short draw reflects very badly on the Azeri player IMHO. Let's hope he gets his comeuppance in the Candidates tournament.
1
