Candidates Round 8: Caruana impresses, wins marathon

by Carlos Alberto Colodro
4/20/2021 – Fabiano Caruana defeated former co-leader Maxime Vachier-Lagrave in round 8 of the Candidates Tournament, once the event resumed a year after having been postponed due to the sanitary crisis. Caruana played a sharp novelty out of a Najdorf Sicilian and eventually got a slightly superior endgame, which he turned into a remarkable victory. In the other decisive game of the day Kirill Alekseenko defeated Alexander Grischuk. Ian Nepomniachtchi is now the sole leader of the event. | Photo: Lennart Ootes

ChessBase 16 - Mega package Edition 2021 ChessBase 16 - Mega package Edition 2021

Your key to fresh ideas, precise analyses and targeted training!
Everyone uses ChessBase, from the World Champion to the amateur next door. It is the program of choice for anyone who loves the game and wants to know more about it. Start your personal success story with ChessBase and enjoy the game even more.

More...

A year-long preparation

The eight-player Candidates tournament is one of the most prestigious global chess events, held every two years. The event will determine who will challenge the defender Magnus Carlsen for the title of the World Chess Champion. 


All the results from round 8:

Name Result Name
Caruana Fabiano   Vachier-Lagrave Maxime
Nepomniachtchi Ian   Giri Anish
Wang Hao   Ding Liren
Alekseenko Kirill   Grischuk Alexander

Round 9 will take place on Tuesday, April 20 at 4:00 p.m. local time. Pairings:

Name Result Name
Alekseenko Kirill   Caruana Fabiano 
Grischuk Alexander   Nepomniachtchi Ian
Giri Anish   Wang Hao
Vachier-Lagrave Maxime   Ding Liren

A crucial encounter finished decisively in the first round of the second half of the Candidates Tournament, after the pandemic forced the organizers to postpone the resumption of the event for over a year. In the main game of the day, Fabiano Caruana climbed to shared second place with a win over former co-leader Maxime Vachier-Lagrave.

Caruana, who was the last player to challenge Magnus Carlsen for the world crown, got a chance to play a sharp novelty against MVL’s Sicilian Najdorf. As stated by the American, his opponent found correct continuations once and again despite having been surprised in a highly complex position. Exhaustion and stress, however, seem to have played a role in the long endgame that ensued, as the Frenchman could not hold a draw from a theoretically balanced but difficult-to-play setup.

A visibly frustrated Vachier-Lagrave analysed a number of variations with his opponent in the post-game press conference. The French star is now tied in second place with Caruana, and enters the last 6 rounds of the tournament with a worse tiebreaker than his American rival (the direct encounter result is the first criterion to break a tie). Both currently stand a half point behind Ian Nepomniachtchi, who drew Anish Giri with the white pieces on Monday.

Caruana’s victory was not the only decisive result of the day, as Kirill Alekseenko needed even more time to take down his compatriot Alexander Grischuk with the white pieces. Grischuk got a good position after surprising commentators and spectators alike by playing the French Defence. The fan favourite over-pressed in the endgame, though, and ended up losing while an exchange up against Alekseenko’s active king and far-advanced passed pawn.

Wang Hao and Ding Liren drew their game rather quickly after playing a deep theoretical line of the Scotch Defence. 

FIDE Candidates 2020/21

Handshakes are back | Photo: Lennart Ootes

Caruana 1 : 0 Vachier-Lagrave

As he has repeatedly done in the past, Vachier-Lagrave stuck to his guns and played his pet Sicilan Najdorf with black — despite knowing all too well that he was facing one of the strongest theoreticians in the world, who had a whole year and a powerful team of seconds to prepare for this very opening. As Olimpiu G. Urcan tweeted:

Love is stronger than pain: Maxime Vachier-Lagrave’s loyalty to his Najdorf is admirable.

It was Caruana who uncorked a novelty, and a shocking one at that.

 

White blitzed out 19.Bc4. While Caruana continued to play his moves almost instantly, MVL had already spent almost 20 minutes on move 18. Moreover, after accepting his opponent’s sacrifice with 19...Qxc4 he needed almost half an hour to find a satisfactory response to the menacing 20.Bd6.

Black considered 20...f5, but correctly (as Caruana said later) opted for 20...Nf6. Magnus Carlsen, who was commentating the games live, thought that the game might end quickly, but the Frenchman showed why he is considered one of the strongest grandmasters in these positions, as he managed to find a way out to enter a difficult yet holdable endgame:

 

In the press conference, Caruana suggested that Black could play the unattractive 26...Ra7 here, which the engines also consider to be the best move. Vachier-Lagrave went for the more human 26...Ne4 and thought he had excellent chances to hold the balance. 

The Frenchman was not wrong, as even the rook and pawn versus knight and pawn ending that was reached on move 50 was a theoretical draw.

 

Of course, White can put pressure on his opponent endlessly from this position. Vachier-Lagrave, who came from surviving a tough surprise in the opening, eventually faltered and had to resign on move 74.

Caruana mentioned that the opening idea had been discovered by Rustam Kasimdzhanov, and that they had it in store “for quite a while”.

 

Fabiano Caruana

A strong (re)start for world number 2 Fabiano Caruana | Photo: Lennart Ootes

Alekseenko 1 : 0 Grischuk

Before the event was postponed last year, Nepomniachtchi had lost a crucial encounter against MVL after playing the French Defence with black. Nepo had also responded to 1.e4 with 1...e6 in round 3 against Alekseenko. However, no one expected for the other Russian in the field to play this defence in round 8. 

Grischuk’s choice surprised the commentators and gave him a large advantage on the clock against his compatriot — a strange occurrence for one of the biggest time-pressure addicts in the circuit. Black also had a good position:

 

Black had the bishop pair and a very stable structure. In hindsight, Alekseenko’s 22.c4 here proved to be a good practical decision, as he went on to activate his pieces quickly — including his king — avoiding having to manoeuvre passively against a player as experienced as Grischuk.

Carlsen praised Alekseenko’s plan to focus on centralization:

 

At this point the engines still give Black a slight edge, but there is plenty of play left in the position. In the ensuing complications, apparently Grischuk could not adapt well to the new situation on the board and rejected lines that led to force draws, which, as often happens, created opportunities for his rival.

Endagme specialist Karsten Müller took a closer look at the endgame, starting from the position in which Grischuk erred decisively by moving his king to the wrong square. A fascinating example of how complicated chess actually is:

 

Kirill Alekseenko

Chess is tough and, at times, rewarding — Kirill Alekseenko | Photo: Lennart Ootes

Nepomniachtchi ½ : ½ Giri

Jon Speelman recently noted that Giri has been playing more straightforward, aggressive chess with great results in the last few months. Against Nepo, the Dutchman played the Sveshnikov Variation of the Sicilian, and later quipped:

I did have one year to find an advantage for black after 1.e4, and I have to say I need a little bit more time.

Giri did not get in trouble, but played what Carlsen considered to be a slightly dubious 18...Be6. However, it was difficult for White to create something concrete. The contenders repeated the position starting on move 24 and agreed to a draw.

 

Carlsen was surprised that Nepo did not continue playing from this position, but the Russian later summed up what had transpired:

White achieved nothing out of the opening, and it was a quick draw.

 

Anish Giri

Sharply dressed, sharply prepared — Anish Giri | Photo: Lennart Ootes

Wang ½ : ½ Ding

In the shortest game of the day, the Chinese representatives in Yekaterinburg played a theoretical line of the Scotch Defence before signing a 28-move draw. Wang talked about what he had done during the past year:

I didn’t consider it necessary to study chess for the whole last year, since I didn’t have any special invitations to online tournaments. [...] I spent quite a lot of time studying and improving my knowledge in the field of investments. I am always happy to use new opportunities and learn something new.

In round 9, Ding will have white against Vachier-Lagrave, while Wang will have the tough task of facing Giri with the black pieces.

 

Ding Liren, Wang Hao

Wang Hao and Ding Liren | Photo: Lennart Ootes


Standings after Round 8

 

All games

 

Links


Carlos Colodro is a Hispanic Philologist from Bolivia. He works as a freelance translator and writer since 2012. A lot of his work is done in chess-related texts, as the game is one of his biggest interests, along with literature and music.

Discuss

Rules for reader comments

 
 

Not registered yet? Register

malfa malfa 4/23/2021 04:45
@ Astuteness,

the issue is neither my level of play, nor yours nor sylicon help, just wondering how a renowned endgame expert could miss a rather standard fortress with plenty of time at his disposal. I agree with you that ignorance is not the reason and my feeling is that it was just the opposite, but please spare me to repeat here what I wrote on the same argument elsewhere: just follow the discussion on Karsten Mueller's specific analysis of the endgame.
Astuteness Astuteness 4/21/2021 10:38
@malfa

It wasn't ignorance. I don't think you or me or anyone in the world would have held against Fabi in that game. Even with the ideal formation Black's task is really hard. What MVL did was spend only 13 seconds for that Nh6 move. That is the mistake. For a player who is playing without Silicon help, it's not easy to understand why the knight on g7 is better than the one on h6.

@celeje
People are sponsored when they deserve it. Caruana is the best player in the world currently. Magnus himself said that Fabi is his biggest threat. Fabi, Wesley and Ian are the only 3 who can think of defeating Carlsen in a match. So getting money for being the best is wrong now? Have some sense.
JoniCee65 JoniCee65 4/20/2021 05:36
I can't believe some of the comments here.
Chess changes, chess evolves, the play becomes more theoretical, the structures better understood, and strategies better executed.
Chess isn't an onion to be pickled.
malfa malfa 4/20/2021 04:34
@ Gerald C

I wonder why a SuperGM should be praised for his defence when he apparently showed ignorance of a very basic concept in the pure R vs N endgame: fianchetto the knight! This setup would have been even more effective with one pawn each as in the game, since the black one enforces the fortress, whereas there is no way to use the white one as a battery-ram. As simple as that. So never underestimate the importance of preparation and never overestimate that of calculation.
fgkdjlkag fgkdjlkag 4/20/2021 03:03
@Gerald C, one should admire Fischer Random, that kind of situation is impossible there.
Blitz2010 Blitz2010 4/20/2021 02:25
@ Gerald C
You selected certain aspects of the game to paint a one-sided, forced picture of it. You could also select other aspects, for example: Why isn't MVL more flexible in his openings so that he can avoid computer preparation? A little more flexibility should be expected from a WC challenger. After all, Caruana highly deserved the point.
celeje celeje 4/20/2021 01:56
@Blitz2010: Maybe MVL doesn't have the huge financial resources Caruana has.
celeje celeje 4/20/2021 01:55
@stierlitz: Caruana has a team of seconds bought with Sinquefield's millions. We should not want chess to be all about money.
stierlitz stierlitz 4/20/2021 12:32
@Getald C
Both players have studied this opening in and out. MVL must have spent tons of hours of his life to be ready to beat his opponents just out of the opening, by repeating memorized moves, no creativity, and the rest is a technique, still getting all the credit for the over-the-board performance. So why should it not be admirable that Caruana edged MVL in this game. Isn't preparation essential component in any professional sport?
Gerald C Gerald C 4/20/2021 09:46
Caruana-MVL.
Modern chess with a theoretical novelty found by the computer which leads to a very sharp and complicated position. White has studied all the lines given by the computer beforehand, black none. Black spends all his energy to stay alive in the opening and middlegame then falters in a theoretical drawish endgame because he is exhausted.
Where is the creativity of the first player and who should one admire ?
1