Berlin GP: Eight draws, players share their opinion on Karjakin’s ban

by Carlos Alberto Colodro
3/24/2022 – All eight games played on Wednesday at the FIDE Grand Prix in Berlin finished drawn, which means Levon Aronian, Leinier Dominguez, Alexandr Predke and Nikita Vitiugov continue to lead their respective pools. After the round was over, Dina Belenkaya asked the players to share their opinion on FIDE‘s decision to ban Sergey Karjakin from competitive chess for six months. | Photos: World Chess

Your personal chess trainer. Your toughest opponent. Your strongest ally.
FRITZ 20 is more than just a chess engine – it is a training revolution for ambitious players and professionals. Whether you are taking your first steps into the world of serious chess training, or already playing at tournament level, FRITZ 20 will help you train more efficiently, intelligently and individually than ever before. 

Keymer’s stubborn defence

For the first time in this year’s Grand Prix series, all games in a single round of the preliminary stage finished drawn. Half of Wednesday’s encounters lasted around 30 moves, while the other half did see some fighting in somewhat imbalanced positions. The two players who got considerable advantages but did not manage to convert them into wins were Andrey Esipenko and Leinier Dominguez.

While Esipenko saw his chances rather swiftly neutralized by Hikaru Nakamura’s defensive efforts, Dominguez’s game lasted no fewer than 80 moves, with Vincent Keymer showing tenacity to hold the balance both in the middlegame and in the ensuing technical endgame.

 

White has an extra pawn, the more active king and the chance to create a passer on the kingside. However, the presence of opposite-coloured bishops in the endgame justifies Black’s decision to offer a queen swap with 44...Qf6.

As Keymer explained afterwards, once the time control had passed, he thought that “normally” he should lose this position if he trades queens, but with the bishops of opposite colours on the board it was “certainly a very difficult and complicated position”.

Both players agreed that perhaps White could have found a way to create a zugzwang position to win the game, although Dominguez would have needed to play extremely precisely to get the desired setup for this to happen. In the end, a draw was agreed in the following position.

 

It was a great showing by the German prodigy, who has worked extensively with none other than Peter Leko, an excellent technical player himself.

 

Leinier Dominguez, Vincent Keymer

Leinier Dominguez trying to find a way to break through against Vincent Keymer

Players’ opinions on Karjakin’s ban

Once the round was over, Dina Belenkaya interviewed a few of the players, and asked them to share their opinion regarding FIDE’s decision to ban Sergey Karjakin for six months after the former World Championship challenger publicly expressed his support for Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

Anish Giri noted that it is difficult for him to understand how FIDE is supposed to deal with the problem, since “it is a pretty unprecedented situation” and he “fortunately does not recollect [similar] cases”.

A bit more willing to share his thoughts on the topic was Maxime Vachier-Lagrave, who first referred to Karjakin’s tweets:

First of all, I think Sergey went over the top in quite a few of his statements. He’s definitely entitled to an opinion, but some of his tweets were in very poor taste.

The Frenchman added that it is not for him to judge whether Karjakin should be banned, as that is the job of the Ethics Committee, although if it depended on him, he would have only issued a warning.

Daniil Dubov

Daniil Dubov

Known for his straightforward opinions, Daniil Dubov first mentioned that he fully agrees with private organizers who have announced that they do not plan to ever invite Karjakin to participate in their tournaments again — i.e. Norway Chess, the London Chess Classic and the Grand Chess Tour. Dubov later explained that he finds FIDE’s decision to be very strange insofar the length of the ban is difficult to justify:

It’s either way more or nothing, that’s my opinion. It’s either, he’s not guilty at all and it’s fine, or it’s at least three years without the game and so on. [...] If we are talking about a topic this big, it cannot be just half a year without chess, which basically means he will just not play the Candidates and then he’s back.

As Douglas Griffin shared on Twitter, apparently Karjakin wants to set up an alternative chess organization to FIDE and has already given up on the idea of participating in the Candidates.

Meanwhile, Wesley So has a more definite stance on the matter. The Filipino-born grandmaster agrees with the ban based on the fact that Karjakin has gained public notoriety only due to his successes as a competitive chess player. So added:

I saw what he’s been writing on Twitter — I have nothing to say against Sergey, but I think he’s lost his mind in the last couple of months. [...] This is not just about a political opinion, but it is about the killing of innocent civilians, innocent Ukrainians.

Wesley So

Wesley So in blue and yellow

Pool A

 
 

Pool B

 
 

Pool C

 
 

Pool D

 
 

Links


Carlos Colodro is a Hispanic Philologist from Bolivia. He works as a freelance translator and writer since 2012. A lot of his work is done in chess-related texts, as the game is one of his biggest interests, along with literature and music.

Discuss

Rules for reader comments

 
 

Not registered yet? Register

rawdzilla rawdzilla 4/10/2022 06:36
My opinion: I agree: FIDE has no business playing politics on the chess board.
FIDE should promote friendship not division.
turok turok 3/27/2022 05:21
this is a joke-this is free speech and his right to say what he wants and if he believes his country is doing what is need it is his choice-when will FIDE stay out of politics-did they ever do anything before with Russia when they were the big country before the wall was taken down and all of those atrocities? Nope they kept playing-sadly we lost many players because FIDE decides to be political. Just play chess-do we know if he is under stress to say such things-what about other things other countries do and those players-stay out of the politic business-he has right to free speech-
Balthus Balthus 3/26/2022 07:11
TwoZero, wonderful regurgitation of Putinist propaganda, you can pat yourself on the shoulder, Sir (?)
fgkdjlkag fgkdjlkag 3/25/2022 08:33
@sebtak, that's all speculation regarding Radjabov and the Candidates. He addressed and explained that comment you mentioned. The covid precautions were obviously inadequate when the Candidates was going to happen. The organizers didn't think it would be that serious and Radjabov foresaw it. He said he was open to playing depending on FIDE's response to his questions regarding covid and whether they were going to take additional measures (which were obviously needed). They decided not to. His decision was correct regardless of what happened after that, but the fact that the Candidates was paused was further evidence he was right. What more do you need? Literally everything is consistent with Radjabov's account. Even look at the interviews with Radjabov before the first half of the Candidates, he's not faking his emotions.

Reg. Salov, I don't put much stock in what he said. He is earnest but having some delusions.
TwoZero TwoZero 3/25/2022 06:26
We are all one.

Unless you are a Russian citizen that has an opinion the West doesn't want you to have...

Remember: "Weapons of mass destruction in Iraq!"

You know, that time the US killed hundreds of thousands of innocent Iraqi citizens for no reason whatsoever?

At least Russians actually found some of the 25-30 biological "Research" labs funded by the US military that had lethal pathogens in them, you know, for study.

As an American I can say that no matter which side you choose to believe; At a minimum this is one big fat case of the US/Western European Pot calling the Russian kettle Black.
ChessTalk ChessTalk 3/25/2022 03:31
Maybe Sergei will be more successful than trump starting his own twitter like format.
sebtak sebtak 3/25/2022 12:33
@Michael Jones, he was saying he didn't have much intention of playing in the Candidates at the end of 2019, before China had communicated on Covid at all. You can find the statement on Chessbase if you look for it. It then became apparent that his replacement would be MVL. At that point, just before the Candidates started, Covid was The thing and I assume it was easier for him to voice concerns over Covid at thee last minute as opposed to repeat what he had already said before, i.e. that he wasn't really interested in the Candidates. I don't think interruption of the candidates - which was for visa/return concerns for the candidates' return and not an actual outbreak - validates his scapegoat argument. Besides, all other candidates had priced the risks, but surprisingly only the person on the record in 2019 for his unwillingness to take part used the argument not to play. Of course, after having missed the first half, it was impossible for him to be allowed back as the results of the first half could not be scraped. But it gave him an opportunity to use it as bargaining material. Let's see if he pulls the same stunt again. Of course, I don't know this for a fact, but it's more plausible than the Covid argument given his 2019 comment on the Candidates and his long history of comments on Armenians.
Michael Jones Michael Jones 3/24/2022 11:35
@Sebtak: you appear to be claiming to read Radjabov's mind here. Covid was the reason he gave for pulling out of the Candidates, and given that it was suspended halfway through because of Covid, it's fair to say that if that was his real reason, he had a valid point. If he had been so keen not to play in it at all, how come he was asking to be allowed to join the tournament once it resumed?
sebtak sebtak 3/24/2022 09:58
@MauvaisFou .... Amen about Radjabov.
His older comments about Armenia and Armenians are still available for everyone to read.
His celebrations on Twitter after the 6 weeks war at the end of 2020 are in no better taste than Karjakin's comments. An approximate 5000 Armenians from Karabakh died in that conflict. Some prisoners of war still haven't been returned despite the post conflict agreements.
At the end of 2019, Radjabov already mentioned he wasn't sure he would play the candidates. Nothing to do with covid, the reason was that he had no intention to play at all from the onset, but wanted to make sure that if he pulled out Aronian wouldn't get a chance to get his spot. As the candidates were to start, and MVL was the replacement according to the rules, Radjabov used covid as his pretext to pull out.
How has Radjabov been 'disciplined'? By giving him a free spot in this year's candidates!
MauvaisFou MauvaisFou 3/24/2022 07:47
What did Salov say ? What about Radjabov and his dubious remarks about Armenia ?
MauvaisFou MauvaisFou 3/24/2022 07:44
SK will be world champion, since I think he can beat Shipov and Karpov in this Chess Federation of their own.
Jacob woge Jacob woge 3/24/2022 05:58
“I'm more interested when the FIDE president is going to be sanctioned.”

Yes, there is a risk Putin will crack down hard.
Mamack1 Mamack1 3/24/2022 05:26
There will be no "new FIDE" of any consequence.
BeTonHan BeTonHan 3/24/2022 01:23
"Have the Chinese players also been asked about their relationship with Xi Jinping and the oppression of the Uyghurs? "
-> No, but they also did not tweet in favour of their repression.
Stupido Stupido 3/24/2022 01:05
The Glavset argument "what about this or what about that" cannot abuse any chess player. As far as I remember the only top players who lowered themselves in obnoxious statements are Alekhine, Fischer and Salov. None of them has ever played an official game of chess after their awful speeches.
arzi arzi 3/24/2022 10:55
To Pionki, "In an interview with Mother Jones, Dvorkovich, who is now president of FIDE, voiced his opposition to the war, becoming one of the very few, or only, former senior Kremlin officials to openly criticize it. "Wars are the worst things one might face in life…including this war," Dvorkovich tells me from Russia, where he says he is "safe with my family and friends."

Has he changed his statements? Going to be sanctioned by whom? By Putin?
drgenial4 drgenial4 3/24/2022 09:06
If he agreed with Afghanistan war, he would be a freedom defender.
kluiz kluiz 3/24/2022 08:38
Have the Chinese players also been asked about their relationship with Xi Jinping and the oppression of the Uyghurs?
lajosarpad lajosarpad 3/24/2022 07:39
If Karjakin founds a new "FIDE", I hope there will be no 13-years-of-darkness this time with two world champions. Yet, FIDE could have prevented that danger from lurking around by avoiding thought-policing.
DuxCarnorum DuxCarnorum 3/24/2022 07:24
Karjakin is apparatchik!
1