Tal Memorial Rd4 – The one that got away

by ChessBase
11/19/2011 – The fourth round was marked by draws on all boards. However, not all draws are equal. To be fair, considering the way the games unfolded, it is quite surprising that there were not a few decisive results. The most distinct game was one that was reminiscent of the classic Botvinnik-Fischer (1962), as Nepomniachtchi escaped from Nakamura in similar fashion. Full report with GM commentary.

Winning starts with what you know
The new version 18 offers completely new possibilities for chess training and analysis: playing style analysis, search for strategic themes, access to 6 billion Lichess games, player preparation by matching Lichess games, download Chess.com games with built-in API, built-in cloud engine and much more.

Sixth Tal Memorial in Moscow

This event is a ten-player round robin event, is taking place from November 16th to 25th in Moscow, Russia. Time control: 100 minutes for the first 40 moves, 50 minutes for the next 20 moves, and 15 minutes for the rest of the game, with an increment of 30 seconds per move starting from move one.

Results

Round 4: Saturday, November 19, 2011
Magnus Carlsen
½ ½
Sergey Karjakin
Peter Svidler
½ ½
Boris Gelfand
Ian Nepomniachtchi
½ ½
Hikaru Nakamura
Levon Aronian
½ ½
Vishy Anand
Vladimir Kramnik
½ ½
Vassily Ivanchuk

Round four

Carlsen-Karjakin: In a game that was incredibly positional, Carlsen slowly outplayed Karjakin. Although it looked very dangerous for the Russian, truth was that he was always in an okay situation. The endgame was visually more dangerous than it really was, and with some good technique he was able to secure the draw. It is hard to say exactly where Magnus went wrong, or if he did, as I am unable to pinpoint a position in which he could have greatly improved on his play.


Sergey Karjakin in the middlegame against his fellow prodigy Magnus Carlsen


Magnus working Sergey in the endgame


Peter Svidler glances over at his friend Vladimir Kramnik playing Vassily Ivanchuk


Vassily Ivanchuk glances up at his opponent Vladimir Kramnik in their game

Kramnik-Ivanchuk: This game saw a viciously aggressive Kramnik try to punish Ivanchuk for his lack of development. Although this meant that Ivanchuk would have a passed pawn on c3 for many, many moves! The gamble payed off, and Kramnik emerged with a significant advantage from the opening. A combination of control over the open files and control over key squares meant that Black was reduced to absolute passivity. However, just when it all looked hopeless, Ivanchuk struck back by sacrificing an exchange to create some serious practical problems. Eventually the game withered into an endgame where Kramnik was an exchange for a pawn ahead, but it was insufficient as his structure was bad and the pawn count very reduced.


Anand kibitzing (left) while Aronian (middle) thinks

Aronian-Anand: This game saw the current World Champion suffer for another draw. Although White's opening looked rather meek, it clearly contained more poison than it let show. Anand quickly saw himself down a pawn from the opening, although for it he had obtained a strong blockade and immense pressure against the isolated, but extra, c-pawn. At one point Anand decides it's time to transpose into an endgame, which he must have been very confident about drawing. To us mere mortals it seemed that Aronian had a lot of winning chances, but again it is hard to say where he could have finished of the Indian Super-GM.


Vishy Anand and Levon Aronian in the press conference after the game (with the
position after move 43 on the board, and Fritz showing its planned continuation)

Addendum: Originally we had written "Fritz showing it's planned continuation" but corrected our hideous mistake after receiving the following message from "André Philidor of Lyons, FR." who wrote:

Heavens! To think that the most erudite minds should partake of such an ignorant error! If these minds apply the carelessness of their diction to their chess, they must be bad players indeed. Any schoolboy knows that "it's" is a contraction of "it is",- the apostrophe replacing the missing letter-, and that "its" is a third person personal pronoun singular possessive neuter. This mistake might be overlooked in a high school newspaper; but in such a prestigious and powerful periodical as ChessBase it is nauseous.

It is depressing to note what errors can be committed by an overworked journalist, who will naturally be taken to the town square and horsewhipped. And ChessBase will of course bear the cost of getting "André", who reads our publications so meticulously, a life. It is something he desperately needs.


Peter Svidler in the middlegame against WCh Challenger Boris Gelfand

Svidler-Gelfand: Probably the only actually dull game of the day. A quick liquidation of the queen-side resulted in a game where Gelfand had some minor pressure, but further piece liquidation boiled the game down into a draw, a direction where it was obviously heading from the start.

All games from round four – select from the dropdown menu on the right above the JavaScript board. Note that the attached PGN file contains the time taken for each move (visible in ChessBase or Fritz).

New ...
Open...
Share...
Layout...
Flip Board
Settings
MoveNResultEloPlayers
Replay and check the LiveBook here
1.Nf3 30 d5 30 2.c4 0 e6 0 3.g3 2:00 dxc4 2:30 4.Qa4+ 30 c6 4:30 5.Qxc4 30 b5 1:30 6.Qc2 1:30 Bb7 3:30 7.Bg2 2:30 Nd7 4:30 8.a4 3:30 a6 2:30 9.0-0 2:30 Ngf6 0 10.Nc3 1:30 Be7 2:30 11.d4 2:30 0-0 12:30 12.Rd1 9:30 c5 3:30 13.axb5 3:30 axb5 30 14.Rxa8 30 Qxa8 0 15.Nxb5 3:30 Be4 5:30 16.Qd2 3:30 cxd4 1:30 17.Nbxd4 3:30 Rb8 5:30 18.Nh4 19:30 Bc5 15:30 19.Qe1 30 h6 0 20.Bxe4 20:30 Nxe4 10:19 21.Be3 2:30 Ndf6 4:30 22.Nc2 2:30 Rxb2 3:24 23.Bxc5 30 Rxc2 28 24.Bd4 4:30 Qa6 0 25.Kf1 4:46 Nd5 5:39 26.f3 5:26 Nd6 40 27.Rc1 1:50 Qc4 27 28.Rxc2 19 Qxc2 3 29.Ng2 3:15 Nc4 52 30.Qa1 1:39 Nd2+ 4:02 31.Kf2 20 Nb3 14 32.Qb2 26 Nxd4 1:04 33.Qxd4 2 Qc3 53 34.Qxc3 4 Nxc3 2 35.Nf4 10 Kf8 5 36.Nd3 6 Ke7 4 37.e4 13 Kd6 11 38.Ke3 0 e5 12 39.Kd2 8 Nb5 3 40.Ke3 0 Nc7 0 ½–½
  • Start an analysis engine:
  • Try maximizing the board:
  • Use the four cursor keys to replay the game. Make moves to analyse yourself.
  • Press Ctrl-B to rotate the board.
  • Drag the split bars between window panes.
  • Download&Clip PGN/GIF/FEN/QR Codes. Share the game.
  • Games viewed here will automatically be stored in your cloud clipboard (if you are logged in). Use the cloud clipboard also in ChessBase.
  • Create an account to access the games cloud.
WhiteEloWBlackEloBResYearECOEventRnd
Svidler,P2755Gelfand,B2744½–½2011A136th Tal Memorial4.4
Aronian,L2802Anand,V2811½–½2011D376th Tal Memorial4.1
Kramnik,V2800Ivanchuk,V2775½–½2011D156th Tal Memorial4.2
Nepomniachtchi,I2730Nakamura,H2758½–½2011B706th Tal Memorial4.5
Carlsen,M2826Karjakin,S2763½–½2011E326th Tal Memorial4.3

Nepomniachtchi-Nakamura


Magnus Carlsen watching the tense blitz phase of Nepomniachtchi-Nakamura


One of the most dramatic games of round four, annotated below by GM Ramírez

New ...
Open...
Share...
Layout...
Flip Board
Settings
MoveNResultEloPlayers
Replay and check the LiveBook here
1.e4 30 c5 30 2.Nf3 0 d6 0 3.d4 0 cxd4 0 4.Nxd4 0 Nf6 0 5.Nc3 0 g6 0 The American super star is going out for blood in this game! He has not been able to create serious winning chances in this tournament, and his game against Svidler was very one-sided in favor of the Russian, so he brings out all of his fighting spirit on Ian! 6.Be2 5:30 Perhaps a slight disappointment for the spectators. The game steers away from the razor-sharp lines of the Yugoslav attack, but this doesn't mean the game will be any less interesting. Bg7 30 7.0-0 0 0-0 30 8.Re1 0 Nc6 0 9.Nb3 30 Be6 1:00 10.Bf1 30 a5 30 11.Nd2?! 8:30 A strange novelty. The more common move is 11.a4 Bxb3 12.cxb3 Nb4 With the idea of e6 next move, which is considered to be fine for Black. 11...a4 0 11...d5 12.exd5 Nxd5 13.Nxd5 Bxd5 looked like a slight edge for Black already, however the move played in the game is just as ambitious. 12.Ndb1 1:30 Although original, this anti-development maneouvre of the knight cannot be recommended. It is not heading for any particularly useful square. Ra5 15:30 13.Na3 2:30 d5 1:30 14.exd5 1:30 Nxd5 6:30 15.Ncb5 1:30 Qc8 23:30 16.c3 1:30 Rd8 3:30 There should be almost no doubt that Hikaru has achieved an excellent position from the opening. 17.Qe2 30 Nc7 2:30 18.Rd1 6:30 Nxb5 6:30 19.Nxb5 30 Ne5 30 20.Na3 7:30 Retreating again to the side of the board... 20.Nd4 Bc4 21.Qe1 Bxf1 22.Qxf1 Rad5 followed by a3 gave Black a dominating position. 20...Rad5 9:30 21.Rxd5 30 Rxd5 30 22.Be3 2:30 Ng4 3:30 23.h3 4:30 Nxe3 30 24.Qxe3 0 Qc6 2:30 Nakamura has now established a stable advantage. He holds the open d-file, the pair of bishops and is overall more active. Although he is still far from winning, he has punished Ian for his dubious play. 25.Nc2 5:00 Qc7 0 26.a3 2:30 Be5 2:49 27.Nb4 1:30 Rd8 6 28.Nd3 30 Bd6 5 29.Re1 1:30 Bf5 1:41 30.g3 5:30 Bxd3!? 7:54 Nakamura tries to dismantle Ian's position in an opposite colored game where he will hold the initiative. It was also possible to tend to the position in a more calm and subtle matter, as he is holding all the trump cards. 30...h5 31.h4 Kg7 with the idea of f6 and e5 comes to mind. 31.Bxd3 0 Bc5 16 32.Qf3 30 Rd6 19 The point, now the f2 AND b2 pawns will be under fire. 33.Re4 1:30 Rb6 4:08 34.Bc4?! 1:30 34.Re2 Rf6 35.Qg2 looks unpleasant but I don't see how Black makes progress. 34...e6 5 35.Re2 30 Bxa3 36.Bxe6 30 Bxb2?! 0 36...Rxb2 Although it is usually not advisable to trade pieces when the opposite colored bishops are on the board and you are trying to play for a win; I believe this was a better move. Although Hikaru has won some queenside pawns, the initiative on the kingside is lost, which means he has to be careful of his own king. The combined power of the passed a-pawn and the pressure he can exert over f2 might still allow him to win this game. 37.Bxf7+!? 1:30 37.Ba2 Bxc3? 37...Ba3 38.Re4 38.Bxf7+ Qxf7 39.Qxc3 leaves the king way too vulnerable to consider winning. 37...Qxf7 36 38.Qd3 30 Re6? 3:45 And Nakamura falters. It is hard to blame him with little time left. It was absolutely essential to take control of d8. 38...Qc7! 39.Re8+ Kg7! 40.Qd4+ Rf6 41.Rd8 Qxc3 42.Rd7+ Kg8 43.Rd8+ Rf8 44.Rxf8+ Kxf8 45.Qd8+ Kf7 46.Qd7+ Kf6 47.Qd6+ Kf5 An Black isn't only not getting mated, the checks run out soon and his extra material should tell. 39.Qd8+ 30 Kg7 30 40.Qd4+ 0 Kg8 0 41.Qd8+ 1:00 Qf8 39:40 42.Qd5 30 Qd6 4 Trying to win. The rook is quite poisoned. 43.Qxd6 1:30 43.Qxe6+ Qxe6 44.Rxe6 Kf8! And since the R can't make it to the a-file, this becomes incredibly dangerous for White. 43...Rxd6 19 44.Rxb2 0 a3 55 45.Ra2 0 Ra6 4 Like in the rest of the game, Black is the one holding all the trump cards, however it is still far from winining. His a3 pawn is quite vulnerable and the pawn count will be dangerously reduced. 46.Kf1 30 Kf7 1:09 47.Ke2 30 Ke6 25 48.Kd3 0 Kd5 6 49.f4 30 h5 3:27 49...Ra4 50.c4+ Kc5 51.g4 lead nowhere for Black. 50.g4 19:30 h4! 5 I like this move, as it makes h3 into another weakness, specially considering what White's only resouce in this position is. 51.c4+ 8:30 Kc5 4 52.Kc3 0 Re6 0 53.Rf2 0 Re3+ 43 54.Kc2 30 Kxc4 5:07 54...Kc6!? Was an intersting study-like move. The idea is to try to catch the f-pawn with the K, while allowing the R to defend and capture pawns. However it mights till not be enough. 55.f5 gxf5 56.gxf5 Kd7 57.Kb1 Rxh3 58.Ka2 Ke7 59.Rf4! 59.f6+? Kf7 60.Rf4 b6 Zugzwang. 59...b6 60.Rd4 Kf6 61.Rf4 And the game is still not won. 54...Kd6 55.Rd2+ is awkward for Black. 55.f5 30 g5 3:39 Controlling the important f4 square. 56.f6 0 Re8 0 56...Rb3 57.Rf4+? Overly cute. 57.Rf1= 57...gxf4 58.f7 Rc3+-+ 57.f7 0 Rf8 0 58.Kb1 1:30 Kd5 1:18 59.Rf5+ 30 Ke6 5 60.Rxg5 0 Rxf7 0 61.Rh5 1:00 b5 0 62.Rxb5 30 Rf3 1:03 63.Rb6+ 3:30 Ke5 1:16 64.Rb5+ 1:30 Ke6 2:30 65.Rb6+ 0 Kd5 17 66.g5 0 Rxh3 0 67.Rb4 0 Ke5 1:06 This endgame with the split pawns is unfortunately for Hikaru drawn. It is reminiscent of the Botvinnik-Fischer endgame from the 1962 Olympiad. The defensive task is not incredibly difficult. 68.g6 0 Kf6 5 69.Rg4 0 Kg7 3 70.Ka2 0 Kh8 0 71.Rf4 30 Kg7 6:53 72.Rg4 30 Rh1 1:07 73.Rb4 4:30 h3 1:57 74.Rb3 0 Kxg6 20 74...h2 75.Rh3 Kxg6 76.Rh8 is a simple draw, since the a3 pawn does not help Black. 75.Rg3+ 1:30 Kf5 23 76.Rc3 30 Ke5 32 77.Rxa3 0 Rh2+ 32 78.Ka1 0 Kf4 4 79.Rb3 0 Rh1+ 1:39 80.Ka2 0 Rh2+ 12 81.Ka1 0 Rh1+ 54 82.Ka2 30 Kg4 34 83.Rb4+ 0 Kg3 30 84.Rb3+ 0 Kg4 2 85.Rb4+ 0 Kg3 3 Hikaru had the advantage the entire game, it seemed like he was about to win in several ocassions, but Ian's combination of resourcefulness and sheer desperation allowed him to scrape a draw from an atrocious opening. ½–½
  • Start an analysis engine:
  • Try maximizing the board:
  • Use the four cursor keys to replay the game. Make moves to analyse yourself.
  • Press Ctrl-B to rotate the board.
  • Drag the split bars between window panes.
  • Download&Clip PGN/GIF/FEN/QR Codes. Share the game.
  • Games viewed here will automatically be stored in your cloud clipboard (if you are logged in). Use the cloud clipboard also in ChessBase.
  • Create an account to access the games cloud.
WhiteEloWBlackEloBResYearECOEventRnd
Nepomniachtchi,I2730Nakamura,H2758½–½2011B706th Tal Memorial4.5


Ian Nepomniachtchi and Hikaru Nakamura in the press conference after the game

You can relive the entire round, or follow the next, in high definition in this extraordinary broadcast page provided by the Russian Chess Federation. All the pictures above are screen grabs from this video.

Standings after four rounds

Remaining Playchess commentator schedule

Date
Commentator
20.11.2011
Sam Collins
21.11.2011
Free day
22.11.2011
Daniel King
23.11.2011
Robert Ris
24.11.2011
Dejan Bojkov
25.11.2011
Daniel King

Schedule and Results

Round 1: Wednesday November 16, 2011
Levon Aronian
½ ½
Magnus Carlsen
Vladimir Kramnik
0-1
Ian Nepomniachtchi  
Vassily Ivanchuk
1-0
Peter Svidler
Vishy Anand
½ ½
Sergey Karjakin
Hikaru Nakamura
½ ½
Boris Gelfand
Round 2: Thursday, November 17, 2011
Magnus Carlsen
1-0
Boris Gelfand
Sergey Karjakin
½ ½
Hikaru Nakamura
Peter Svidler
½ ½
Vishy Anand
Ian Nepomniachtchi
½ ½
Vassily Ivanchuk
Levon Aronian
½ ½
Vladimir Kramnik
Round 3: Friday, November 18, 2011
Vladimir Kramnik
½ ½
Magnus Carlsen
Vassily Ivanchuk
0-1
Levon Aronian
Vishy Anand
½ ½
Ian Nepomniachtchi
Hikaru Nakamura
0-1
Peter Svidler
Boris Gelfand
0-1
Sergey Karjakin
Round 4: Saturday, November 19, 2011
Magnus Carlsen
½ ½
Sergey Karjakin
Peter Svidler
½ ½
Boris Gelfand
Ian Nepomniachtchi
½ ½
Hikaru Nakamura
Levon Aronian
½ ½
Vishy Anand
Vladimir Kramnik
½ ½
Vassily Ivanchuk
Round 5: Sunday, November 20, 2011
Vassily Ivanchuk
  Magnus Carlsen
Vishy Anand
  Vladimir Kramnik
Hikaru Nakamura
  Levon Aronian
Boris Gelfand
  Ian Nepomniachtchi
Sergey Karjakin
  Peter Svidler
Round 6: Tuesday, November 22, 2011
Magnus Carlsen
  Peter Svidler
Ian Nepomniachtchi
  Sergey Karjakin
Levon Aronian
  Boris Gelfand
Vladimir Kramnik
  Hikaru Nakamura
Vassily Ivanchuk
  Vishy Anand
Round 7: Wednesday, November 23, 2011
Vishy Anand
  Magnus Carlsen
Hikaru Nakamura
  Vassily Ivanchuk
Boris Gelfand
  Vladimir Kramnik
Sergey Karjakin
  Levon Aronian
Peter Svidler
  Ian Nepomniachtchi
Round 8: Thursday, November 24, 2011
Magnus Carlsen
  Ian Nepomniachtchi
Levon Aronian
  Peter Svidler
Vladimir Kramnik
  Sergey Karjakin
Vassily Ivanchuk
  Boris Gelfand
Vishy Anand
  Hikaru Nakamura
Round 9: Friday, November 25, 2011
Hikaru Nakamura
  Magnus Carlsen
Boris Gelfand
  Vishy Anand
Sergey Karjakin
  Vassily Ivanchuk
Peter Svidler
  Vladimir Kramnik
Ian Nepomniachtchi
  Levon Aronian

Links

The games are being broadcast live on the official web site and on the chess server Playchess.com. If you are not a member you can download a free Playchess client there and get immediate access. You can also use ChessBase 11 or any of our Fritz compatible chess programs.

Copyright ChessBase


Reports about chess: tournaments, championships, portraits, interviews, World Championships, product launches and more.

Discuss

Rules for reader comments

 
 

Not registered yet? Register

We use cookies and comparable technologies to provide certain functions, to improve the user experience and to offer interest-oriented content. Depending on their intended use, analysis cookies and marketing cookies may be used in addition to technically required cookies. Here you can make detailed settings or revoke your consent (if necessary partially) with effect for the future. Further information can be found in our data protection declaration.