Proposing a new system for top tournaments

by Miguel Illescas Córdoba
6/22/2019 – Entrepreneur, trainer, and Grandmaster Miguel Illescas puts down some thoughts on how to make elite chess touranments more fan friendly. Inspired by the Norway Chess Armageddon experiment, he offers a proposal to improve the format with tweaks to the scoring and time control. We encourage you to offer feedback in the comments below.

YOUR PERSONAL CHESS COACH - Whether you’re taking your first steps into the world of club chess, or already playing at a tournament level: with FRITZ, you can train more efficiently, intelligently and with a more personalised approach than ever before.
FRITZ is more than just a chess engine – it’s a training revolution! Whether you’re taking your first steps into the world of club chess, or already playing at a tournament level: with FRITZ, you can train more efficiently, intelligently and with a more personalised approach than ever before.

An improved Armageddon?

The Norway Chess tournament is finally over, so it is a good time to analyze the conclusions that we can extract from the “Armageddon” experiment. First, we must praise the organizers for achieving this wonderful show, and commensurate audience records. 

Draws: A real problem

The first aspect that grabs our attention is that the percentage of draws in the Norway Chess has been increasing year after year, apart from 2015, and in this edition, draws have beaten all records. Three out of four games ended up in a draw.

Norway Chess

Year 1-0 Draws 0-1 Games Draw %
2019 7 34 4 45 76%
2018 8 28 3 39* 72%
2017 10 31 4 45 69%
2016 12 30 3 45 67%
2015 15 25 5 45 56%
2014 10 28 7 45 62%
2013 16 21 8 45 47%

* Ding Liren retired after three rounds 

A logical explanation for this fact is that the players that take part in the Norway Chess are world-class chess players and, as a consequence, they make very few mistakes. In addition, these players are facing constantly throughout the year, and they know each other very well. 

When the field is mixed, the percentage of draws is lower, as it occurs in the Tata Steel tournament, for example:

Tata Steel Masters (Group A) 

Year 1-0 Draws 0-1 Games Draw %
2019 20 54 17 91 59%
2018 25 55 11 91 60%
2017 23 57 11 91 63%
2016 22 61 8 91 67%
2015 28 45 18 91 49%
2014 23 30 13 66 45%
2013 28 50 13 91 55%

And if we analyze tournaments with younger players or lower Elo ratings, this percentage of draws goes down, as we can see in Tata Steel Chess Challengers (Group B): 

Tata Steel Chess Challengers (Group B)

Year 1-0 Draws 0-1 Games Draw %
2019 24 49 18 91 54%
2018 18 55 18 91 60%
2017 32 37 22 91 41%
2016 28 36 27 91 40%
2015 31 36 24 91 40%
2014 35 35 21 91 38%
2013 34 34 23 91 37%

We understand now why there are so many draws in tournaments like Norway Chess, and a look to the past will confirm it. In the famous tournaments in Linares, back in the 80s and the 90s, the percentage of draws was much lower, between a 40% and a 50%. But when the number of players was reduced, and the level of the field increased, this percentage rose dramatically, reaching more than 70%. Once again, we had the same problem: all players were world-class and they knew each other too well.

The Sofia-Corsica rule, prohibiting draw offers before move 30, has improved this situation. However, there are still many short or boring games, especially when white plays in a very solid way. 

A lot of draws will occur when the best players face each other. Thus, the idea of declaring a winner in each round using rapid chess makes a lot of sense, especially if we want chess to be more attractive to the general public. Here are my suggestions for improvement:

A winner every time

In each round a match winner shall be proclaimed. If the first game is a draw, another game will be played with the remaining time, and so on, until someone wins a game. The time spent on each move takes enormous value. 

Colours balance

The player who is white in the first game will play black in the rest. In this way, the chances of each player are balanced, and short draws in the first game are discouraged. 

Scoring

The winner in each round receives one point, the loser zero. Easy to understand for the public and the press.

Rating

For rating calculation each game is computed separately in the corresponding modality (classic, rapid or blitz), depending on the duration of the game. 

Time control

handshakeEach round has a maximum duration, which the organizers establish according to their convenience. 

In all games, the players have 3 seconds per move, not cumulative, plus an initial time:

  1. For the first game each player has two and a half hours, or less, according to the attached table.
  2. For the second game, each player has the time not consumed in the first game, plus 15 or 30 minutes.
  3. For the rest of the games, the players will have only their remaining time. 

The time of 3 seconds per move is not cumulative. If a player moves in 3 seconds or less, his clock remains stopped. After the first 3 seconds, it begins to consume the main time, until it is exhausted, in which case he loses on time. There is no need for the players to record the games, the electronic boards or the arbiters can do the job. 
 
Each player has a time based on the maximum duration of the round, set by the organizer.

Round
max. duration
Time each player receives ... ... ...
  1st game 2nd game More games In all games
7 hours 150 minutes Remaining time + 30 min. Remaining time 3 seconds per move
6 hours 120 minutes Remaining time + 30 min. Remaining time 3 seconds per move
5 hours 120 minutes Remaining time + 15 min. Remaining time 3 seconds per move
4 hours 90 minutes Remaining time + 15 min. Remaining time 3 seconds per move
3 hours 60 minutes Remaining time + 15 min. Remaining time 3 seconds per move

The idea that we have seen in the Norway Chess is good, but I think it can be better. To give 1½ points to the winner of the Armageddon game makes things unnecessarily complicated, not to mention that we must explain that a draw is good for black in the second game, etcetera.

What do you think?


Miguel is a Spanish chess player born in Barcelona. He is the editor of the chess magazine "Peón de Rey" and contributes to the daily newspaper "La Vanguardia" where he tests readers with different chess moves.

Discuss

Rules for reader comments

 
 

Not registered yet? Register

Archnimzo Archnimzo 6/22/2019 04:06
I agree with rokko, In my opinion draws are not a problem, are part of the game, and a draw is not necessarily boring, with this measures the quality of chess might drop, and that will be boring,
KevinC KevinC 6/22/2019 04:00
@klklkl If the initial starting position is not the same, no, it is not. It is certainly a variant, and certainly "a relative", but it is not chess. Why do you have to call it "Chess 960", or as others call it, "Fischer Random"? Why? Because it IS different.
hansj hansj 6/22/2019 03:26
Draws are not a problem, but quite normal.
If some masters have a boring style of play - well, sponsors might invite them less often.
rokko rokko 6/22/2019 03:22
Those who look only at the cross tables do not like draws in general.

But all these "solutions" generate less interesting classical games and more draws - as Norway chess showed.

Those who do not like classical chess can enjoy rapid and blitz - but all this hybrids (blitz endgames in Norway, pressure to save time in the above proposal) only reduce the quality of the chess (I prefer a tense draw to a blunder festival).

If you look at sports without direct elimination (e.g. league football) draws are part of life and nobody proposed a penalty shootout each weekend.
klklkl klklkl 6/22/2019 02:51
The beauty of Norway's armageddon experiment was that it was easy to understand. The format proposed above is interesting, but introduces unnecessary complexity. But it's an interesting start. The problem exists, despite the insistence from some that the status quo is fine. Top level chess is becoming dull, not because of draws, but because of the manner of the draws. Forced lines, prepared by seconds, memorised sometimes beyond the 40th move, lines where the player doesn't begin his game until the endgame or needs no thought other than orientation and recall until the endgame. Worse still the cautious attitude from White, perhaps the result of Black receiving so much attention from seconds.

It's in everyone's interests for elite tournaments to have a mass audience. More attention means more events, greater interest from sponsors, better earnings for players and in time, a wider pool of elite players. But with the traditional format, hell, even Rex Sinquefield's classical innovations, it isn't going to change.

Norway's a great start.
klklkl klklkl 6/22/2019 02:37
@KevinC Chess 960 very definitely IS chess. Everything is the same, except the initial line-up.
johorsky johorsky 6/22/2019 02:35
This is worth trying. However, win in the first game (regular time) might be 3 points, and win in tie-break games (overtime) 2 points, and 1 point for the tie-break loser. Thus winning the classical game would be worth more than winning the tie-break. Some sports use this scoring.
drbas drbas 6/22/2019 01:49
Nothing wrong with a draw, it's a perfectly valid result. (chess is a draw anyway mathematically). Nothing wrong with the full length classical timecontrol with no draw offers before the first timecontrol (40) and only increments from the 2nd (60).
Give 0 points for a draw (since maintaining status quo), +1 point for a won game (since one successfully exploited an opponent's inaccuracie(s), and -1 point for loosing. (One under performed, allowing to be exploited for a win.)
KevinC KevinC 6/22/2019 01:48
@ musketeerchess Just because you use chess pieces and the same movements, variants are not chess. They are something else that is closely related, but it is not chess since it does not adhere to the rules of chess on the FIDE site.
chipstaylor chipstaylor 6/22/2019 01:41
Time increment is too low. 10 secs delay is more appropriate.
stumpy stumpy 6/22/2019 01:40
Why not link prize money to points scored?

for example $1000/point and nothing for half a point - so at the end of a tourny some one who scores 7.5 points only receives £7000. so you have to earn 2 draws to get $1000 but nothing for the odd one.

(please scale up the prize money to suit the prize fund)
testviking testviking 6/22/2019 01:29
I like the point system with 0 points for a loss, 1 point for a draw and 3 points for a win. I also like the rule that draw offers are only allowed after 40 moves. Combining these two should be sufficient to increase the motivation to play for a win. Furthermore, I think that draw is a valid result and should not be settled with an additional game. This set of rules can be used for games with any time control. As for making chess more interesting to the public and the press, I think this mission lies on the shoulders of people and infrastructure involved in live commenting. I have seen considerable improvements over the years. Keep up the good work and we will fool more people into spending their time on this beautiful board game.
Justjeff Justjeff 6/22/2019 01:19
The lesson here is clear - rapid/blitz simply attracts more interest. So get rid of "standard" time controls completely.

Purists will argue that this will rob us of the artistry of deep conceptions. But we already have correspondence for that, and no, correspondence play doesn't generate any sponsors either. Maybe there's a lesson here ... if you want to get paid, play faster. If you want to play for pure enjoyment, fine, but don't expect sponsors to feel the same way.
Tedz Tedz 6/22/2019 01:05
Interesting, but the clock timings are complicated. I would support the 3 points for a win 1 for a draw, and amend the prize money according to their points score.
musketeerchess musketeerchess 6/22/2019 12:59
Elite Chess should include more Chess Variants. The are funnier, much less draws, much less opening theory and leaves more place for human creativity.
www.musketeerchess.com