Edward Winter's Chess Explorations (49)

by ChessBase
11/1/2010 – Truly exquisite play occurred in a little-known game won by Capablanca, at breakneck speed, in a simultaneous exhibition (St Petersburg, 1913). The Editor of Chess Notes presents some text-book discussion and cooperation on the subject among his readers. The pawn ending, involving the complexities of the distant opposition, gives rise to a number of highly instructive manoeuvres.

ChessBase 17 - Mega package - Edition 2024 ChessBase 17 - Mega package - Edition 2024

It is the program of choice for anyone who loves the game and wants to know more about it. Start your personal success story with ChessBase and enjoy the game even more.


Chess Explorations (49)

By Edward Winter

White to move

In C.N. 1715 Kenneth Neat (Durham, England) drew our attention to this position, discussed on page 35 of Kapablanka v Rossii by V. Linder and I. Linder (Moscow, 1988). The co-authors quoted an account by Romanovsky in Shakhmaty v SSSR, 1959 No. 60 of a simultaneous display by Capablanca in St Petersburg on 24 November 1913 (old style), in which he scored +24 –3 =3. The relevant extract from the book is given below, in Dr Neat’s translation:

‘A more tenacious resistance to Capablanca was offered by Kalantarov, one of Romanovsky’s friends from the Polytechnic Institute. [In the above position] it was the grandmaster’s turn to move. Kalantarov and his consultants, including Romanovsky, expected 46 Ke7, since they thought that after 46 Kf7 the knights would be exchanged, and the pawn ending would favour Black. Great was their astonishment when Capablanca nevertheless played his king to f7. The players rapidly made two more moves each: 46...Ng5+ 47 Nxg5 fxg5 48 g4! “This move”, recalls Romanovsky, “as well as all those following, was made instantly by Capablanca.” When the Cuban had moved away from the board, they began calculating variations, and saw that in the event of 48...a5 White would continue 49 h4 gxh4 50 g5, when the g-pawn decides the game in his favour. Therefore there followed: 48...Kh7 49 h4 Kh6 50 Kf6! (if now 50...gxh4 then 51 g5+ Kh7 52 Kf7 h3 53 g6+ and White wins) 50...Kh7 51 h5! a5 52 Ke5 Resigns.’

Subsequently, in C.N. 1741, René Olthof (Rosmalen, the Netherlands) wrote:

‘I used C.N. 1715 in one of my training sessions and now I think the position is nothing special.

First of all, 48 g4! is not necessary at all. In fact, the normal 48 h4 is much easier, viz. 48...g4 49 Ke6 a5 50 Kd5 or 48...gxh4 49 g4 h3 50 g5 h2 51 g6 h1(Q) 52 g7+ Kh7 53 g8(Q)+ Kh6 54 Qg6 mate.

Of course, 46...Ng5+ is horrendous. After normal moves like 46...Ng7 I consider the position to be drawn, since the outside passed a-pawn is too troublesome for White. Hence, 46 Ke7 and 46 Kf7 are objectively equal, since neither is enough to win. (46 Kf7 does set a trap, though.)’

A dozen years later Karsten Müller (Hamburg, Germany) wrote to us (in C.N. 2402):

‘I disagree with Mr Olthof. I think that 46 Kf7 was clever as it set a trap which was not at all easy to spot. Furthermore 48 g4! is the only move that wins the pawn ending. 48 h4? g4! 49 Ke6 a5 50 Kd5, as proposed by Mr Olthof, leads only to a draw, with 50...Kg7 51 Kc4 Kf6 52 Kb5 Ke6 53 Kxa5 Ke5!, as Black can maintain the (distant) opposition. So I consider Capablanca’s play in the knight ending a great achievement for a simultaneous display.’

Position after 53...Ke5

We searched our database and found two games (a win and a draw) with the identical (mirror-image) position as at the end of Karsten Müller’s distant opposition line. A comparable position, though with the kings located elsewhere, arose in the fourth match-game between Staunton and Williams, London, 1851. On page 330 of his book on the London, 1851 tournament Staunton pointed out that the decisive mistake was 56 Ke5. ‘56 Ke4 would have maintained the opposition, and drawn secundum artem. The move in the text enables [Black] to win!’

Acknowledging the correctness of Karsten Müller’s remarks, René Olthof pointed out, concerning the above-mentioned win in the database, that the defender gave away the opposition twice:

E. Schmittdiel-N. Heck, Bad Zwesten, 1997

65 Kf3 Kd5 66 Kg3 Ke5 67 Kh2 Ke4 (67…Kd4 keeps the opposition) 68 Kh3 (nor does the consistent move 68 Kg2 win after 68…Kd4 69 Kf3 Kd5) 68…Kd5 69 Kg2 Ke4 70 Kh2 Kd5?? (70…Kd4!=) 71 Kh3! Kd4 72 Kh4 Kd5 73 Kh5 Kd4 74 Kg6! Kc5 75 Kg5 Kc6 76 Kf4! Kd5 77 Kf5 Kd4 78 Ke6! Kc5 79 Ke5 Kc6 80 Kd4! Resigns.

Finally, in C.N. 2432 we added that the Capablanca v Kalantarov ending was discussed by Pal Benko in Chess Life (January 1990, pages 74-75, and June 1991, page 13). The drawing procedure indicated in C.N. 2402 was demonstrated slightly differently, i.e. by the line 48 h4? g4 49 Ke6 Kg7 50 Kd5 Kf7 51 Kc5 Kg7 52 Kb5 Kf7 53 Ka6 Kf6 54 Kxa7

54...Ke7! (distant opposition) 55 Kb6 Kd6 56 Kb5 Kd5 57 Kb4 Kd4 58 Kb3 Kd5.

Submit information or suggestions on chess explorations

All ChessBase articles by Edward Winter

Edward Winter is the editor of Chess Notes, which was founded in January 1982 as "a forum for aficionados to discuss all matters relating to the Royal Pastime". Since then, over 6,800 items have been published, and the series has resulted in four books by Winter: Chess Explorations (1996), Kings, Commoners and Knaves (1999), A Chess Omnibus (2003) and Chess Facts and Fables (2006). He is also the author of a monograph on Capablanca (1989).

Chess Notes is well known for its historical research, and anyone browsing in its archives will find a wealth of unknown games, accounts of historical mysteries, quotes and quips, and other material of every kind imaginable. Correspondents from around the world contribute items, and they include not only "ordinary readers" but also some eminent historians – and, indeed, some eminent masters. Chess Notes is located at the Chess History Center. Signed copies of Edward Winter's publications are currently available.

Reports about chess: tournaments, championships, portraits, interviews, World Championships, product launches and more.


Rules for reader comments


Not registered yet? Register