Boris Johnson, chess and Brexit metaphors

by André Schulz
7/26/2019 – Boris Johnson has completed an improbable rise to the top of British politics. After the resignation of Theresa May as the United Kingdom's Prime Minister, Johnson is next in line to unravel the Gordian knot of the so-called "Brexit". Back in 2014, as the Mayor of London, he was a guest at the London Chess Classic and spoke clever things about the game of chess. But is his game up to the task ahead?

ChessBase 15 - Mega package ChessBase 15 - Mega package

Find the right combination! ChessBase 15 program + new Mega Database 2019 with 7.6 million games and more than 70,000 master analyses. Plus ChessBase Magazine (DVD + magazine) and CB Premium membership for 1 year!

More...

"The greatest mental game ever invented"

Boris Johnson, best known as the mayor of London, is the new Prime Minister of Great Britain after Theresa May failed to "deliver Brexit" and resigned as PM and Conservative Leader on June 7th

Full of pithy statements on a variety of topics, and totally eschewing "political correctness", Johnson has been as polarizing a figure in the U.K. as Donald Trump has been in the USA.

The new Prime Minister has been one of the most energetic advocates of Britain's swift exit from the European Union even, if necessary, without any agreement on conditions of its departure. Now Johnson's rhetoric is on a collision course with reality and set to come to a head on October 31st...scary.

Brexit chess pieces

Boris you say? Should be a good chess player...

It turns out Boris is his middle name, and the new Prime Minister has quite an interesting ancestral picture.

Alexander Boris de Pfeffel Johnson, was born in 1964 in New York. His great-grandfather was Ali Kemal, briefly Foreign Minister of the Ottoman Empire in 1919 and murdered in 1922 at the behest of Nureddin Pasha. Johnson's grandfather emigrated to England and adopted the name "Wilfried Johnson". Another family line in Johnson's pedigree includes the German nobles Adelheid Pauline Karoline von Rottenburg, illegitimate daughter of Prince Paul of Württemberg, and Karl Maximilian Freiherr von Pfeffel. Johnson is even distantly related to the British royal family. 

From 1999 to 2005, Johnson was editor of the news magazine The Spectator. In 2001 he became member of the British House of Commons. From 2008 to 2016 he was Mayor of London, then became Foreign Minister (until 2018). This week he was elected to head the ruling Conservative Party, putting him in line to succeed Theresa May as Prime Minister.

While mayor of London in 2014, Johnson attended the London Chess Classic and expressed his enthusiasm for chess as an educational tool.

"Chess is a wonderful game, it teaches rules and discipline, it is a fantastically logical game, and I think the sheer mental strain of it diverts the childrens’ natural energies which might otherwise go into doing naughty things. It’s to be encouraged. It’s the greatest mental game ever invented."

Mayor Johnson visits the 2014 London Chess Classic

More video evidence via Twitter via Olimpiu Urcan:

Translation from German: Macauley Peterson


An angry stalemate

By Macauley Peterson

Chess is of course a frequent metaphor in political discourse, often with unintentional humour and Brexit is no exception. Below are some of the highlights.

One of the earliest and well-known references came from chess journalist John Saunders:

"Brexit: What will six-month extension mean?" (BBC)

[W]hat follows is likely to be more of the same: an angry stalemate fought against the backdrop of a profoundly divided country more sceptical than ever about the very fitness of the political system.

"The true reason Britain cannot call Europe’s bluff" (Prospect Magazine)

In trade, both sides lose—albeit the UK more substantially as a percentage of its economy than the EU, simply due to the difference in size. But in the world of regulators, all the consequences are on the UK side. The EU would have a regulatory system on 31st March 2019 which functioned exactly the same as the one on 30th March, except for the absence of the UK. Britain would have a black hole.

But actually, the problem of infrastructure covers trade too. In the absurdly named war cabinet, ministers will spend the next week or so debating the UK’s customs arrangements. It is equivalent to playing chess and calling it military campaign. There is no infrastructure being built to enact the demands that they are making.

Three-dimensional chess?

"Brexit is a game of three dimensional political chess - and Jeremy Corbyn has made his biggest move yet." (Sky.com)

"Triggering Article 50 is just the first move in a game of fantastically complicated 3D chess" was the headline of an article way back in April 2017 on the website of "The UK in a Changing Europe"

The phrase three dimensional chess is a concept popular among social scientists, denoting a series of interlinked social ‘games’, each of which impacts on, and is affected by the other. Brexit means we may all become familiar with the concept.

Three dimensions not enough? How about four?

"Everyone needs to be prepared for a speed-chess Brexit – especially Labour" (The Guardian)

The recent World Chess Championship set a new record, but it was not one likely to give the game more mass appeal. There were 12 slow matches, conducted in a soundproof glass box, between the reigning champion and his challenger – and every one ended in a draw. The contest was finally resolved only by quickening the pace with a deciding run of games in which the players had to think and move much more rapidly.

Something similar is going to happen with the four-dimensional version of chess known as Brexit. Grinding deadlock will be ultimately resolved by a fast-moving tiebreaker phase.

"Brexit is a steady game of chess – Labour is right to play the long game" (unitebrexitcheck.org)

We’ve learnt that the Brexit process is a steady game of chess not a sudden tug-of-war. There are many actors, of which Labour is just one. Advantage builds slowly, through successive moves. And it’s hard to see ahead very far into the future.

Is it Zugzwang or checkmate?

"If the Brexit negotiations are a game of chess, Theresa May is dangerously close to checkmate" (The Telegraph)

"Theresa May Put Her Head on the Block for Her Brexit Deal. It Might Not Be Enough." (The New York Times)

What remained to be seen was whether, like a chess player giving up her queen, she had managed to win the game on her last move."

In fact, while making no mention of chess, one of the best analysis of the whole Brexit situation comes from Grandmaster Jonathan Rowson, in his article "Brexit, Democracy and the Sacred".

Have you seen any chess / Brexit references you'd like to share?

Use the feedback to the editors link below!

  • Brexit and the Queen Sacrifice (EU Observer)
  • Brexit is the ‘chess game of our lives,’ says Emily O’Reilly (The Irish Times)

David Arganian from Seattle writes:

He’s actually the great great great grandson of De Rivière (Morphy’s opponent) through his mother’s side of the family!




André Schulz started working for ChessBase in 1991 and is an editor of ChessBase News.
Discussion and Feedback Join the public discussion or submit your feedback to the editors


Discuss

Rules for reader comments

 
 

Not registered yet? Register

Mr TambourineMan Mr TambourineMan 7/29/2019 02:06
Yep Even more: Paul Morphy and Caissa . Draw?
Mr TambourineMan Mr TambourineMan 7/29/2019 02:01
I missed some names that have been name-dropped here.
More attentive readers might be able to find even more?

De Rivière - Emily O’Reilly 1-0
Prince Paul of Württemberg - Karl Maximilian Freiherr von Pfeffel 0-0
Alexander Boris de Pfeffel Johnson - Winston Churchill 0 - 1
The Turk - Jayarama Iyer 0 - 1
Emmanuel Macron - Facebook 1/2 - 1/2
Jayarama Iyer Jayarama Iyer 7/28/2019 06:14
Was scared of Boris Johnson, but he seems to be an interesting, delightful guy now.
Hope he lifts UK up like his idol, Winston Churchill.
Thumbs up to his love and support for chess.
Mr TambourineMan Mr TambourineMan 7/28/2019 01:29
Theresa May - Donald Trump 0 - 1
Ali Kemal - Nureddin Pasha 0 - 1
Wilfried Johnson - Adelheid Pauline Karoline Maximilian Freiherr von Pfeffel 0 - 1
Queen Elisabeth - Olimpiu G. Urcan 0 - 1
Malcom Pein - Icon 0 - 1
David Chan - Naughty Things 0 - 1
Macauley Peterson - John Saunders 1 - 0
Jeremy Corbyn - Walk Over 0 - 1
Jonathan Rowson - Zebra 1 - 0
David Arganian - André Schulz 1/2 - 1/2
Namamajon - EU Bureaucrat 1 - 0
GrayDuck GrayDuck 7/28/2019 06:24
Why is Boris Johnson misquoted in this article? (I am assuming he is quoted on what he said in the video, which was similar but had substantial differences in wording.)
namamajon namamajon 7/28/2019 04:32
All this talk about brexit being 3D or 4D is all just bla bla bla to cover this simple fact: the people wanted out of the European Union, the ruling class didn't, and they've been trying to stop it all this time.

And the people didn't want out of the EU because of trade deficits or any such nonsense, they wanted out because of politics, because you are being ruled by an entity you have no control over, because rules are forced upon you that you don't agree with, because the EU only serves globalism, not the people.

Nobody really needs the concept of the EU anyway. Yes you have one currency, but that does not compensate for everything else. Europe functioned perfectly fine before the EU existed.

As a matter of fact the NUMBER ONE ECONOMIC TOOL for any nation is the ability to control it's own currency - if you have one - and in the EU you gave that tool away, meaning you are at the mercy of whatever the EU wants. Greece learned that lesson (or should have). The people of France are starting to learn that lesson. (Macron is a globalist.)

While austerity is forced upon the people, trillions upon trillions are hiding in tax shelters.
Aighearach Aighearach 7/26/2019 08:47
Chess games don't work out very well for the sorts of people who like to use chess metaphors to describe their politics.

Caissa doesn't care how right you think you are. She doesn't mind leaving a line that violates all your attempts at rules of thumb or positional philosophies. It is about her, not the player.

Every player must discover this, or flee the game in terror of having to play those who accepted it.
1