World Championship: Game 4 drawn amid 'videogate'

by Macauley Peterson
11/14/2018 – The fourth game of the World Chess Championship in London between Magnus Carlsen and Fabiano Caruana also ended without a winner. With White, the World Champion did not get anything out of the English opening and on the 34th move, he offered to draw. That left spectators pondering over the potential ramifications of a video promoting Caruana which may have inadvertently provided the Carlsen camp with insights into the Challenger's opening preparation. | Pictured: Ellisiv Reppen makes the ceremonial first move for Carlsen | Photos: Nadia Panteleeva / World Chess

ChessBase 15 - Mega package ChessBase 15 - Mega package

Find the right combination! ChessBase 15 program + new Mega Database 2019 with 7.6 million games and more than 70,000 master analyses. Plus ChessBase Magazine (DVD + magazine) and CB Premium membership for 1 year!

More...

Match tied at 2 points apiece

In the first three games of this World Championship match, White has been unable to prove much whether it be Carlsen or Caruana making the first move. Caruana was in a losing position in Game 1, then Carlsen was a bit worse in Game 2's Queen's Gambit, and the third game micro-advantage Caruana got with the white piece in his repeat of the Rossolimo evaporated by the endgame. Each time the point was shared.

Magnus was the first to arrive to Game 4. He sat down at the board and meticulously filled out his scoresheet before leaving in the direction of the players' rest area — which is shared between the competitors — adjacent to the stage and guarded 24/7 by security. There one can find two small grey couches, two small white refrigerators and a snack table.

Fabiano soon arrived, took his place on the black side of the table and cracked open a bottle of still Isklar water (Magnus prefers sparkling).

Carlsen and Caruana handshake

The players have been shaking hands on mutual arrival and at the start and end of the games | Photo: Macauley Peterson

Ellisiv Reppen was invited to make the first move. She has a popular Norwegian chess book for children that came out in 2014 and was translated to English in 2016 under the title Be the King! She’s also the partner of Grandmaster Jan Gustafsson, who’s thought to be reprising his role as an opening analyst on Team Carlsen during the match.


Game 4 video summary

GM Daniel King provides a 5-minute look at the main events of the day:


Petroff, QGD and Fianchetto Grunfeld oh my!

Speaking of openings, Carlsen and his squad of seconds may have gotten an unexpected gift on Tuesday morning, when a video clip providing a behind-the-scenes glimpse of a Caruana training camp was noticed to contain a potentially sensitive list of games in a ChessBase window, including opening files.

If real, this could potentially disrupt the game plan of the Caruana team by revealing their areas of focus in the opening. There are a few reasons to suspect that this was indeed an accidental slip-up, rather than a "hoax" or disinformation.

  1. The screen was innocuous enough to the untrained eye to have been overlooked
  2. The video was promptly removed from YouTube as soon as the presumably-damaging frames were publicised through Twitter
  3. Caruana's demeanour at the press conference, when asked about the video, was one of sincere annoyance (though this one is subjective, and unfortunately it was not captured on camera by the official webcast's camera operator)

(We contacted three people affiliated with the Saint Louis Chess Club or the Caruana team in an effort to confirm the video's contents, but did not receive a response.) 

On the other hand, maybe it's no big deal:

GM Miguel Illescas Vladimir Kramnik's second in his 2000 World Championship match

It's worth noting that PlayMagnus promoted a similar video in advance of the match, but this one had elements selectively obfuscated to avoid the possibility of damaging information becoming public.

Another day another draw

In the game, Carlsen had to carry the "burden" of white pieces again, although he would later say that he regards the difficulty he and his challenger have had with white as a bit of a fluke.

Grandmaster Alex Colovic made several bold predictions in advance of the match, one of which was that he expected "to see Carlsen start the match with something he won’t play afterwards". Several other predictions have been wrong (e.g. he figured Carlsen would play both 1.e4 as White and 1...e5 as Black in response to 1.e4), but this one, at least for a day holds up.

The World Champion opened with 1.c4, the first time we have seen an English Opening in the match. Caruana answered 1...e5 and there followed a kind of Sicilian Defence with reversed colours.

Carlsen brought out the English Opening in London

 

In the past, Black's dark-squared bishop used to go to e7 almost automatically but then, last year, Alexander Grischuk was the first player from the world's elite who came up with the idea that the bishop could be developed to c5 analogous to the Sozin variation. Since then, this idea has gained traction, and with its appearance in a World Championship match, that's likely to continue.

This would not have surprised Carlsen, considering Caruana has already developed in this way in prior games, notably in June of this year in a game against Wesley So in Paris which the players followed until move 11.b4. As is common in the Sicilian, Carlsen pursued a minority attack by advancing his queenside pawns, but after a queen trade, the game then flatlined quite fast leading Carlsen to offer a draw after his 34th move. 

No problems in a reversed Sicilian


Game 4 press conference


Analysis of Game 4 by GM Michael Adams
 

Look for more detailed analysis from GM Adams in the next issue of ChessBase Magazine!

Match standings

 

Round-up shows


All games of the match

 

Andre Schulz contributed reporting

Links




Macauley is Editor in Chief of ChessBase News in Hamburg, Germany, and producer of The Full English Breakfast chess podcast. He was an Associate Producer of the 2016 feature documentary, Magnus.
Discussion and Feedback Join the public discussion or submit your feedback to the editors


Discuss

Rules for reader comments

 
 

Not registered yet? Register

macauley macauley 11/15/2018 09:17
@saguni - This is a question for World Chess, but as I understand it games 10 and 11 just went on sale, and I would expect game 12 will follow shortly.
saguni saguni 11/14/2018 07:17
I'm visiting London for a week on Nov 22nd. How do I buy the ticket for the last day - Nov 28th? Its not on sale via Ticketmaster. Are they sold out? Does any one know? Thanks
bbrodinsky bbrodinsky 11/14/2018 02:40
The "scandal" of the video is as exciting as the match itself.... They really have to increase the number of games AND the number of video scandals in world's championship matches!
jsaldea12 jsaldea12 11/14/2018 02:20
Carlsen has more experience and stamina, but Caruana takes yoga. That makes it even between the two. Both play by the book. He who losts nerves and deviates from the book will loss. Carlsen has this weakness. Caruana has to play steady and stay calm. He has good chances of taking home the championship.
Jarman Jarman 11/14/2018 09:59
It's true that in such a high-stakes match (especially one between two players so close rating-wise) every small detail counts, but this is nothing but a storm in a teacup. On the other hand, I think the PlayMagnus video should have been remade from scratch - what's the point in releasing a bunch of mostly obfuscated footage? Either you release it in full after the match or you show people analyzing and discussing without the board.
Nostalgiac1972 Nostalgiac1972 11/14/2018 06:44
And Maybe having that exposed in the footage was a carefully contrived trick by team Caruana, and we are yet to see interesting things as the match goes on.
Grey Hiker Grey Hiker 11/14/2018 04:18
The video is much ado about nothing.

The games of the Carlsen-Karjakin match (surprise!), lots of Petroff lines with no detail useful at GM preparation levels (Caruana has frequently played the Petroff), and a Queen's Gambit Declined line with 10) Rd1, Re8 (highly topical with a piece sac).

Probably the information that Caruana's team was looking at a specific line of the QGD [and no doubt several hundred other things] might be mildly interesting to Carlsen (Caruana is not normally a QGD player), but even when the QGD line with 10) Rd1 unexpectedly appeared on the board, Caruana surprised Carlsen with the relatively rare 10)... Rd8 (not ... Re8).
1