Praggnanandhaa misses a shot at his final GM norm

One norm still remains

The youngest International Master on the face of the planet, IM R Praggnanandhaa, has been trotting fervently around the globe to earn his required GM norms for the grandmaster title. Since he has already hit the 2500 rating threshold, all that remains between him and the coveted title is one grandmaster norm — he had earned his first one at the world junior championship, last year; and his second at the Heraklion Fischer Memorial GM Norm tournament in Greece, in April this year.

Currently, the 12-year-old is in the Netherlands, playing at the Schaakweek Apeldoorn closed round robin. The tournament is a 10-player event with a time control of 90 minutes for 40 moves, followed by an additional 30 minutes for the rest of the game with 30 seconds increment from move one. The field includes some very strong players from the Netherlands and around the world. Some top names include GM Alexandr Fier, GM Tiger Hillarp Persson and the local star GM Ernst Sipke. To achieve a GM norm, a player must score a minimum of six points out of his nine games.

Praggnanandhaa won stylishly against FM Max Warmerdam in the third round | Photo: Henk Vinkes/Schaakweek Apeldoorn

Praggnanandhaa is seeded fourth by rating in the tournament but has had a tough outing so far. After seven rounds of play, Praggnanandhaa has only managed to score two wins. This means that he has missed the opportunity to score his final norm. Even if he wins all of his remaining games, he will remain two points short.

In the third round against FM Max Warmerdam the little genius pulled off a stylish miniature that lasted merely 26 moves. Praggnanandhaa had opened with 1.d4 but the game soon steered into the waters of the Pirc Defence after a transposition of moves. This was, perhaps, a welcome development for Praggnanandhaa who went on the offensive right from kick off.

Praggnanandhaa won stylishly against FM Max Warmerdam in the third round | Photo: Jeron Ponstijn/Schaakweek Apeldoorn

Storming his pawns up the board thematically, Praggnanandhaa generated a dangerous looking attack on the black king. Warmerdam tried creating instant counter chances with a wing attack of his own but blundered in the heat of the battle on his 16th turn. This gave Praggnanandhaa a decisive material advantage along with a continued attack. Warmerdam tried his luck at finding perpetual checks but after a few precise moves by Praggnanandhaa, it was lights out.

The Modern Pirc

The Modern Pirc is actually a mixture of the Caro-Kann and the Pirc. In many lines Black combines the ideas of the classical Pirc in which the fianchettoed bishop is important with the Caro-Kann idea to fight for the center with c6-d5.

Praggna’s first-round game against the local GM Ernst Sipke was also a very interesting one. He had the white pieces in this game too and was successful in carving out a palpable edge in the middle game that arose from a King’s Indian Fianchetto. Trying to convert his positional edge into a material advantage, Praggna gave up his dark-squared bishop for Sipke’s knight, netting a pawn out of the transaction. But after the game, Praggna himself pointed out that this gave his opponent too much counterplay.

Also, within a few moves after this, the ticking clock began to make its presence felt and the Indian prodigy succumbed to the pressure. A string of bad moves starting with 38.Bxh3 caught Praggna’s king in an unavertable mating net by the time the first time control was reached.

A short interview with Praggnanandhaa | Schaakweek Apeldoorn

King's Indian: A modern approach

Bologan: "If you study this DVD carefully and solve the interactive exercises you will also enrich your chess vocabulary, your King's Indian vocabulary, build up confidence in the King's Indian and your chess and win more games."

Praggnanandhaa played ambitiously in round 2 against Hugo Ten Hertog but this only backfired | Photo: Schaakweek Apeldoorn

After this loss, an ambitious attempt at bringing home the full point backfired terribly at the Chennai lad in round two, when he audaciously gave up an exchange to make something of his connected queenside passers.

Pragganandhaa, with black, went for the enterprising 33...Rxc5 here, giving himself two queenside passers after 34.bxc5. But within just four moves, Ten Hertog was able to encircle these passers and hack them off before they could pose any threats. After this, Praggnanandhaa went down pretty fast.

King's Indian Attack

The King’s Indian Attack is a unique opening system in that it offers White a dynamic and interesting game but without the need to know reams of theory. In addition to being easy to learn it has an excellent pedigree, leading exponents including great players such as Bobby Fischer, Tigran Petrosian, David Bronstein, Viktor Korchnoi, Leonid Stein and Lev Psakhis. GM Nigel Davies presents a complete repertoire for White.

Praggnanandhaa during his fourth round game against IM Jose Rafael Gascon Del Nogal | Photo: Henk Vinkes/Schaakweek Apeldoorn

Something similar happened in the fourth round where, again, Praggnanandhaa, playing against IM Jose Rafael Gascon Del Nogal, placed his bets on his queenside passers. After a tumultuous first time control, the following position was reached.

Now Praggnanandhaa could have pressed for a win after 41…Rxa1 42.Bxa1 Qb1+ 43.Kg2 Bb7+ 44.Kh3 and 44…c3 (not 44.Qxa1 because of 45.Qc2). But Praggna went for 41…Rxg3 and went on to lose after blundering four moves later.

Despite all setbacks, however, Praggnanandhaa has been fighting tooth and nail in every game. Unfortunately, one accident or another lost him crucial points. In the fifth round, again, he had a decent position against the second seed of the tournament and a regular annotator in our reports, GM Tiger Hillarp Persson.

Black is threatening 41...Be5, winning the exchange. The computer thinks Praggnanandhaa should have saved the exchange with 41.Nf3. Instead, he played 41.Kd2, making room for the rook to retreat. But this gave the Swedish GM just a little bit to bite on, as he was able to punch in 44…d4 eventually and invade with his pieces. A couple of more inaccuracies by Praggnanandhaa in the remainder of the game only expedited the outcome.

Round 5 was another unfortunate disaster | Photo: Henk Vinkes / Schaakweek Apeldoorn

With this loss, any remaining hopes of scoring a norm in Apeldoorn had dissipated. Even if Praggnanandhaa had won all of his remaining games by this point, he would not make it to the 6-point-mark. The sixth round did provide some respite when he pulled off his second miniature of the tournament against IM Stefan Kuipers but a loss against IM Arthur Pijpers in round 7 put him back on the bottom of the table. 

After seven rounds, Dutch IMs Thomas Beerdsen and Hugo Ten Hertog are leading the tournament with a score of 5/7. As for Praggnanandhaa, he is tenth on the leaderboard with only two points in his kitty out of seven games.

Standings after seven rounds

Rk.		Name	Rtg.	Nt.	Pts.	n	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10	TB	Perf.
1	GM	Ten Hertog,H GM Ten Hertog,H 2453 1 GM Gascon Del Nogal,J 2470 ½ 2 GM Praggnanandhaa,R 2507 1 3 IM Kuipers,S 2477 1 4 IM Pijpers,A 2479 1 5 GM Beerdsen,T 2454 ½ 6 GM Fier,A 2576 1 7 GM Ernst,S 2555 0 8 GM Hillarp Persson,T 2546 ½ 9 GM Warmerdam,M 2370 ½ Ø 2493 6/9	2453		6.0	9		½	½	1	1	0	½	1	1	½	25.50	2618
2	GM	Hillarp Persson,T GM Hillarp Persson,T 2546 1 GM Warmerdam,M 2370 1 2 GM Beerdsen,T 2454 0 3 GM Gascon Del Nogal,J 2470 1 4 GM Fier,A 2576 0 5 GM Praggnanandhaa,R 2507 1 6 GM Ernst,S 2555 ½ 7 IM Kuipers,S 2477 1 8 GM Ten Hertog,H 2453 ½ 9 IM Pijpers,A 2479 1 Ø 2482 6/9	2546		6.0	9	½		0	0	1	½	1	1	1	1	23.75	2607
3	GM	Beerdsen,T GM Beerdsen,T 2454 1 IM Pijpers,A 2479 ½ 2 GM Hillarp Persson,T 2546 1 3 GM Fier,A 2576 1 4 GM Ernst,S 2555 ½ 5 GM Ten Hertog,H 2453 ½ 6 GM Warmerdam,M 2370 1 7 GM Gascon Del Nogal,J 2470 ½ 8 GM Praggnanandhaa,R 2507 0 9 IM Kuipers,S 2477 0 Ø 2493 5/9	2454		5.0	9	½	1		1	0	½	1	½	0	½	23.50	2536
4	GM	Fier,A GM Fier,A 2576 1 IM Kuipers,S 2477 ½ 2 IM Pijpers,A 2479 0 3 GM Beerdsen,T 2454 0 4 GM Hillarp Persson,T 2546 1 5 GM Ernst,S 2555 1 6 GM Ten Hertog,H 2453 0 7 GM Warmerdam,M 2370 1 8 GM Gascon Del Nogal,J 2470 ½ 9 GM Praggnanandhaa,R 2507 1 Ø 2479 5/9	2576		5.0	9	0	1	0		½	1	1	0	1	½	21.50	2522
5	IM	Kuipers,S IM Kuipers,S 2477 1 GM Fier,A 2576 ½ 2 GM Ernst,S 2555 1 3 GM Ten Hertog,H 2453 0 4 GM Warmerdam,M 2370 ½ 5 GM Gascon Del Nogal,J 2470 1 6 GM Praggnanandhaa,R 2507 0 7 GM Hillarp Persson,T 2546 0 8 IM Pijpers,A 2479 1 9 GM Beerdsen,T 2454 1 Ø 2490 5/9	2477		5.0	9	0	0	1	½		1	½	1	0	1	20.50	2533
6	GM	Ernst,S GM Ernst,S 2555 1 GM Praggnanandhaa,R 2507 1 2 IM Kuipers,S 2477 0 3 IM Pijpers,A 2479 1 4 GM Beerdsen,T 2454 ½ 5 GM Fier,A 2576 0 6 GM Hillarp Persson,T 2546 ½ 7 GM Ten Hertog,H 2453 1 8 GM Warmerdam,M 2370 0 9 GM Gascon Del Nogal,J 2470 ½ Ø 2481 4.5/9	2555		4.5	9	1	½	½	0	0		0	1	1	½	19.50	2481
7	GM	Warmerdam,M GM Warmerdam,M 2370 1 GM Hillarp Persson,T 2546 0 2 GM Gascon Del Nogal,J 2470 1 3 GM Praggnanandhaa,R 2507 0 4 IM Kuipers,S 2477 ½ 5 IM Pijpers,A 2479 1 6 GM Beerdsen,T 2454 0 7 GM Fier,A 2576 0 8 GM Ernst,S 2555 1 9 GM Ten Hertog,H 2453 ½ Ø 2502 4/9	2370		4.0	9	½	0	0	0	½	1		1	0	1	16.50	2459
8	IM	Pijpers,A IM Pijpers,A 2479 1 GM Beerdsen,T 2454 ½ 2 GM Fier,A 2576 1 3 GM Ernst,S 2555 0 4 GM Ten Hertog,H 2453 0 5 GM Warmerdam,M 2370 0 6 GM Gascon Del Nogal,J 2470 1 7 GM Praggnanandhaa,R 2507 1 8 IM Kuipers,S 2477 0 9 GM Hillarp Persson,T 2546 0 Ø 2490 3.5/9	2479		3.5	9	0	0	½	1	0	0	0		1	1	13.50	2410
9	GM	Praggnanandhaa,R GM Praggnanandhaa,R 2507 1 GM Ernst,S 2555 0 2 GM Ten Hertog,H 2453 0 3 GM Warmerdam,M 2370 1 4 GM Gascon Del Nogal,J 2470 0 5 GM Hillarp Persson,T 2546 0 6 IM Kuipers,S 2477 1 7 IM Pijpers,A 2479 0 8 GM Beerdsen,T 2454 1 9 GM Fier,A 2576 0 Ø 2487 3/9	2507		3.0	9	0	0	1	0	1	0	1	0		0	14.00	2362
10	GM	Gascon Del Nogal,J GM Gascon Del Nogal,J 2470 1 GM Ten Hertog,H 2453 ½ 2 GM Warmerdam,M 2370 0 3 GM Hillarp Persson,T 2546 0 4 GM Praggnanandhaa,R 2507 1 5 IM Kuipers,S 2477 0 6 IM Pijpers,A 2479 0 7 GM Beerdsen,T 2454 ½ 8 GM Fier,A 2576 ½ 9 GM Ernst,S 2555 ½ Ø 2491 3/9	2470		3.0	9	½	0	½	½	0	½	0	0	1		13.25	2366
TBs: Sonneborn-Berger

Links

• Official site
• All games via Live.ChessBase.com
• More stories about Praggnanandhaa