Alexandra Kosteniuk wins Monaco GP

by Shahid Ahmed
12/15/2019 – Alexandra Kosteniuk had a fairytale ending as she defeated Elisabeth Paehtz in the final round to finish at 7.0/11. For her winning the tournament, the most anticipated match between Humpy and Goryachkina needed Humpy to win and fortuitously that's what happened, resulting in Humpy finishing runner-up and Goryachkina claiming the second runner-up position. Kosteniuk won her third consecutive tournament in a row. Humpy still leads the GP points table. | Photo: Karol Bartnik / FIDE

Chess Endgames 9 - Rook and Minor Piece Chess Endgames 9 - Rook and Minor Piece

Endings with rook and minor piece against rook and minor piece occur very frequently, even more often than rook endings, yet there's not much literature on them. This endgame DVD fills this gap. The four different material constellations rook and knight vs rook and knight, rooks and opposite coloured (and same coloured ) bishops and rook and bishop vs rook and knight are dealt with. In view of the different material constellations Karsten Mueller explains many guidelines like e.g. "With knights even a small initiative weighs heavily".


Grand Prix points and prize money shared

Chess Queen Alexandra Kosteniuk won European Women Individual Rapid and Blitz tournament before Monaco GP. Throughout the event, Kosteniuk was never even in the lead. However, in the last round she scored a crucial win and clinched the championship. Humpy needed to beat Goryachkina for Kosteniuk to become champion and that is exactly what happened in their highly anticipated final round match.

Final standings


Kosteniuk's must-win game

The former Women's World Champion beat Elisabeth Paehtz on demand. Analysing her game afterward, she said the Caro-Kann came as a surprise. "I prepared for anything else but the Caro-Kann. I had a thought of what if, but then I thought okay." 


Kosteniuk continued, "Elisabeth repeated the line Mariya Muzychuk already played with me, but I decided to deviate a bit and take on f6, because I didn't have time to analyse what happened to my game with Mariya."


The eventual champion Kosteniuk felt that her pawn structure is better here.


"I don't know why Elisabeth decided to prevent me from castling long. You know, sometimes you should let your opponent do what she wants. I think ♞d7-♜e8-♞f8 is more usual approach in this system for black. Because after 9...a6 she doesn't let me castle long or at least now it looks very dangerous for me, but I can castle short as well." Kosteniuk said.


"She spent a lot of time here. If I play c4 and just 0-0, my position is very, very pleasant. That's why I considered mostly for her 11...♝d5. I was not sure whether I need to (short) castle or I can play 12.♗e2 or ♘h4. Probably 12.♗e2 is the move I like the most. 12.0-0 is also what I like but after 12...♝xf3 13.gxf3 I couldn't evaluate the position. I always have this double pawn and my king is weaker. But how to get to the king is not clear. Anyway 11...♝d5 was the main move I considered for her."


"Honestly I think I should have played 14.c5 and 14...b4 is the only move. Now she is playing without a piece, okay for a pawn but I think I have very good compensation, 15.♕c2 g6. 15...g6 or h6 I am not sure. And then transfer either my knight or bishop to d6. Looked very powerful to me but since I hesitated about the evaluation, I was not so sure because she will push her a-pawn and her position is very solid."


"Here I went for this attack, although I couldn't of course evaluate all the consequences in the position. It felt like I have a very nice initiative but my position, I liked it very much. Of course, I was blaming myself at a certain point. I played all-in but in this situation I don't know, I am not sure if it was the right decision because it requires sacrificing. I didn't calculate of course everything."


Can you find the winning continuation for white?


Kosteniuk on how she felt after winning the game and if she was nervous before the game,

No, actually it was funny because when I got back home, my husband looked at the table and said, 'Well it's such a nice situation, you win tomorrow and Goryachkina loses and you are first.' and I didn't even have this idea that that would be possible for me in any situation to get first. Actually Grand Prix for me and everyone else is a very hard tournament. To finish with a plus score, is a wish come true already, but to finish with a +3, doesn't matter what place I take. Actually it's like I am very happy and I am back to 2500 rating. Yesterday it was 2499. This year has been very difficult for me in Classical chess starting from May to September I was losing points, rating in every single classical tournament I played. Since I played non-stop, it was like -80 or something like that. But I have had nice results in rapid and blitz, so I won't complain. It is my last classical game for this year. Of course I am very happy to win it and to finish the tournament so well. Because it's a very strong tournament.

When asked about if she had taken a look at the other game, "I didn't have time. Well I mean, I looked at first but then after ♘c4, when I went all-in I didn't have time to look or think because it felt like a very pleasant position with no risk but then I found a way to complicate it."

Kosteniuk won her game when it mattered the most | Photo: Karol Bartnik / FIDE

Humpy bested Goryachkina in a long battle

Humpy beat Goryachkina in their highly anticipated match. In the opening, Humpy played 6.d3 instead of the 6.♕c2 which she has been playing in the recent times. 


Humpy felt that Black shouldn't have played 16...c3, as she loses a pawn, although it's an opposite colour bishop endgame. Can you find out a better continuation for black.


Goryachkina gave away a pawn which she should have defended.


What should Black have done instead?



Find out the better continuation for Black here

Humpy felt Black again missed a strong continuation and keeping the queens on the board was a better idea.



Black's final blunder of the game was 48...f5. It was all over after this. Humpy thought that black should have played 48...♚e7 instead.


Humpy beat Goryachkina in their first encounter since her return | Photo: Karol Bartnik / FIDE

Lagno beats Cramling

Kateryna Lagno got an advantage out of the opening which she did not have much trouble in conversion. In the endgame she showcased her technical prowess to convert her material advantage. 


Lagno scored an emphatic win | Photo: Karol Bartnik / FIDE

A Muzychuk and Gunina had a short but exciting draw

Even if Anna Muzychuk won her last round game, she would have finished fifth as Kateryna Lagno had won her game. However, Gunina fought bravely despite having a forgettable tournament. She tried to spice things up by sacrificing a piece, however Anna is not known to crumble easily, she defended easily and a draw was agreed after a repetition of moves on move 33.


Anna Muzychuk talks about her performance in the tournament and more | Video: FIDE

Gunina would be glad that the tournament is finally over | Photo: Karol Bartnik / FIDE

Zhao ends on a winning note

Harika completely misplayed the opening against Zhao Xue in the final round. She was in trouble out of the opening. But later Zhao misplayed and Harika managed to equalize. However, Zhao played the rook and knight ending correctly and liquidated into a winning rook ending. 


Zhao Xue shares her tournament impression | Video: FIDE

M Muzychuk had a hard fought draw with Dzagnidze

Out of the opening, Mariya seemed to have obtained a decent advantage. However, Dzagnidze played carefully and made sure she stays out of trouble. The game eventually liquidated into a queen ending where draw became the obvious outcome of the game.


Mariya talks about how she fared in the tournament | Video: FIDE

Nana Dzagnidze talks about her performance in the tournament | Video: FIDE

Players at the Closing Ceremony | Photo: Karol Bartnik / FIDE

Pairings of Round 11


All games and commentary


Live commentary by GM Iossif Dorfman and IM Almira Skripchenko along with WGM Keti Tsatsalashvili | Video: FIDE


Shahid Ahmed is the senior coordinator and editor of ChessBase India. He enjoys covering chess tournaments and also likes to play in chess events from time to time.


Rules for reader comments


Not registered yet? Register

Stupido Stupido 12/16/2019 07:28
Another great win for Kosteniuk, always sharp and playing interesting chess.
genem genem 12/16/2019 02:34
Maybe Paehtz (as Black) did not want Kosteniuk to castle long because - chess games wherein the two players castle to opposite wings are 10% less likely to be drawn (are more likely to end with a victory for one color or the other). Alexandra continues to add to her already stellar career.
tigerprowl3 tigerprowl3 12/15/2019 11:16
Why is it that men's chess has tiebreaks but women's chess doesn't?