Ganguly beats Shankland in match with Venceslav Rutar's scoring system

by ChessBase India
9/5/2024 – Surya Shekhar Ganguly defeated Sam Shankland in their 8-game online match with the unique scoring system devised by Venceslav Rutar - which changes the scoring of draws into three categories based on the material disparity. Surya won the match by a 26-11 score, after grabbing 5 wins. Shankland collected 1 win, and 3 games ended in 'equal draws'. While there were no 'favoured' nor 'unfavoured' draws in the match, the format advocated for fighting chess as we got to see so many interesting games.

ChessBase 18 - Mega package ChessBase 18 - Mega package

Winning starts with what you know
The new version 18 offers completely new possibilities for chess training and analysis: playing style analysis, search for strategic themes, access to 6 billion Lichess games, player preparation by matching Lichess games, download Chess.com games with built-in API, built-in cloud engine and much more.

More...

By Rasika Ratnaparkhi

Day 1

Surya Shekhar Ganguly took the lead by scoring 17 points (3 wins and 1 'equal draw') on the first day of his match against Sam Shankland.

The first game featured missed chances and beautiful tactics, but Ganguly capitalised on a blunder by Shankland (29.Ba3?) to dominate the position. In the second game, Shankland missed a winning attack and suffered a significant loss. The third game was an interesting endgame with bishop and 3 pawns against a rook - it was a very hard position for Shankland and Ganguly ended up winning the game. The fourth game was what is described by the format as an 'equal draw'.

After the games, the event organizer, Venceslav Rutar, joined the livestream on the ChessBase India YouTube channel and shared his opinion. (Find all details about the scoring system below in this article).

Game 1: Shankland 0 - 5 Ganguly

The match started off with this wild game where both players missed many chances and there were plenty of beautiful tactics. Here's the first one of them:

White actually built up a better position out of the opening, but this was a serious error from Shankland. Ganguly did not spot the refutation, played 14...Re7 and White found the nice 15.Nxb7! Rxb7 16. Rxc6 winning a pawn and getting a better position. But here Ganguly had a beautiful idea with 14...Re6! 15. Nxb7 Qe7! and the White Knight gets trapped and eventually captured.

Sam couldn't convert his advantage well, and this was the final mistake by him. Can you figure out how Ganguly finished off the game here?

New ...
Open...
Share...
Layout...
Flip Board
Settings
MoveNResultEloPlayers
Replay and check the LiveBook here
1.d4 10 d5 10 2.c4 4 e6 1 3.Nc3 4 Nf6 2 4.cxd5 4 exd5 0 5.Bg5 6 Be7 2 6.e3 6 0-0 1 7.Nf3 31 h6 21 8.Bf4 42 Re8 14 9.Bd3 22 c5 14 10.dxc5 34 Bxc5 1 11.0-0 1 Nc6 1 12.Rc1 7 Bg4 64 13.Nb5 37 Bb6 5 14.Nd6? 9 Re7? 5 14...Re6 15.Nxb7 Qe7! 16.Qa4 Qxb7 17.Ba6 Qd7 18.Bb5 Re4 19.Qc2 Rc8 20.Ba6 Bxf3! 21.Bxc8 Qxc8 22.Qxc6 Qxc6 23.Rxc6 Be2 24.Rfc1 d4-+ 15.Nxb7! 5 Rxb7 0 16.Rxc6± 2 Ne4 17 17.Be2 49 Bc5 22 18.Qc2 37 Qe7 24 19.Rc1?! 27 Bd7?! 105 19...Qe8! 20.Ne5 Bxe2 21.Qxe2 f6 22.Qa6 Rb6 23.Rxb6 axb6 24.Qb7 fxe5 25.Bxh6! gxh6 26.Qxd5+ Kh8 27.Qxe4= 20.Rxc5 132 Nxc5 3 21.Qxc5 1 Qxc5 0 22.Rxc5± 1 Rxb2 0 23.Nd4?! 58 Rc8 4 24.Bc7?! 46 Rb7 57 25.Bd6 4 Rxc5 1 26.Bxc5 1 Rb1+ 0 27.Bf1 1 Bc8 0 28.Nb3 66 a5= 50 29.Ba3?? 75 Rd1! 31 30.h4 42 Ba6 17 31.Nd2 1 Bd3!-+ 2 Normal 0–1
  • Start an analysis engine:
  • Try maximizing the board:
  • Use the four cursor keys to replay the game. Make moves to analyse yourself.
  • Press Ctrl-B to rotate the board.
  • Drag the split bars between window panes.
  • Download&Clip PGN/GIF/FEN/QR Codes. Share the game.
  • Games viewed here will automatically be stored in your cloud clipboard (if you are logged in). Use the cloud clipboard also in ChessBase.
  • Create an account to access the games cloud.
WhiteEloWBlackEloBResYearECOEventRnd
Sam Shankland2618Surya Sekhar Ganguly25850–12024D35Venceslav-Rutar Scoring System Match

Game 2: Ganguly 5 - 0 Shankland

Shankland built up a completely winning position with the black pieces, but things went south for him towards the end. This is a big chance he missed, one that would have allowed him to finish the attack:

The beautiful tactical shot 41...Ne1! finishes the game here for White. 42.Rxe1 is met with 42...d3! and soon Black wins the rook by force - the resulting position with queen and bishop for Black against the white queen should be comfortably winning.

But Shankland played 41...Qe4? and after 42.Qxe6 White is back in the game.

49...Kb8 was the losing mistake for Shankland - do you see why? White to play and win.

New ...
Open...
Share...
Layout...
Flip Board
Settings
MoveNResultEloPlayers
Replay and check the LiveBook here
1.e4 10 c5 10 2.Nf3 1 d6 1 3.d4 1 cxd4 1 4.Nxd4 1 Nf6 1 5.Nc3 0 Nc6 1 6.Bg5 19 Bd7 1 7.Qd2 20 a6 4 8.Nxc6 8 Bxc6 1 9.f3 0 e6 12 10.0-0-0 19 h6 32 11.Be3 4 Be7 80 12.Ne2 3 b5 31 13.Nd4 2 Bb7 1 14.g4 7 Nd7 17 15.Kb1 21 Qc7 29 16.h4 9 Ne5 55 17.Be2 23 h5?! 72 18.gxh5! 15 d5 104 19.Bf4 61 Rxh5 34 20.Bg3 108 0-0-0 88 21.f4 68 Nc4 3 22.Qe1 7 Rh6 12 23.e5 11 g6 27 24.Bg4 64 Kb8 28 25.h5 37 Rc8 22 26.Bh4 27 Bxh4 54 27.Rxh4 3 gxh5 66 28.Rxh5 3 Rg6 12 29.Be2 64 Rcg8 82 30.Rh1 31 Qc5 14 31.Bf3 60 Rg3 10 32.Qf2 13 b4 24 33.Kc1 47 Qa5 41 34.Kb1 2 Qc5 10 35.Rhg1? 41 Nd2+! 37 36.Kc1 1 Nxf3 21 37.Rxg3 40 Rxg3 2 38.Nc6+ 1 Qxc6 4 39.Qxg3 1 d4-+ 5 40.Qg8+ 1 Ka7 12 41.Qxf7 0 Qe4? 14 41...Ne1‼ 42.Rxe1 d3 43.c3 43.Kd2 Qxc2+ 44.Ke3 d2 45.Rf1 Qc1 46.Kf2 Qxf1+ 47.Kxf1 d1Q+-+ 43...Qg2 44.Kb1 Qc2+ 45.Ka1 d2 46.Qxb7+ Kxb7 47.a3 dxe1R+ 48.Ka2 b3# 42.Qxe6 8 Qxf4+ 7 43.Kb1 2 Nd2+ 16 44.Ka1 2 Qf3 4 45.Rc1= 97 Qe3 1 46.Rd1 2 Qe2 8 47.Rc1 1 Nc4 15 48.Qe7 4 Qd2 2 49.Qc5+ 2 Kb8?? 1 50.Rf1 21 Bc8 17 51.Qxc4+- 5 Normal 1–0
  • Start an analysis engine:
  • Try maximizing the board:
  • Use the four cursor keys to replay the game. Make moves to analyse yourself.
  • Press Ctrl-B to rotate the board.
  • Drag the split bars between window panes.
  • Download&Clip PGN/GIF/FEN/QR Codes. Share the game.
  • Games viewed here will automatically be stored in your cloud clipboard (if you are logged in). Use the cloud clipboard also in ChessBase.
  • Create an account to access the games cloud.
WhiteEloWBlackEloBResYearECOEventRnd
Surya Sekhar Ganguly2585Sam Shankland26181–02024B61Venceslav-Rutar Scoring system Match

Game 3: Shankland 0 - 5 Ganguly

This game featured a study-like endgame consisting of bishop and 3 pawns against the rook. Practically, this is very hard for the side with the rook - Shankland in this case. But the entire game had so many beautiful resources!

We would invite our readers to study this game deeply, and leave you with two positions.

61...f4 actually lets the win slip away from Black. Can you find what should White play to hold the draw, and what should Ganguly have played instead?

This was the last chance for White to save the game - how should Shankland respond to 62...Kf5 by Ganguly?

New ...
Open...
Share...
Layout...
Flip Board
Settings
MoveNResultEloPlayers
Replay and check the LiveBook here
1.d4 10 d5 10 2.c4 3 e6 1 3.Nf3 2 Nf6 2 4.Nc3 4 Bb4 2 5.Bd2 5 0-0 6 6.cxd5 2 exd5 4 7.a3 0 Be7 3 8.Bf4 17 c6 20 9.h3 13 Re8 30 10.e3 5 Bf5 2 11.g4 27 Be4 16 12.g5 4 Bxf3 5 13.Qxf3 1 Ne4 0 14.Nxe4 162 dxe4 0 15.Qg4 15 Qa5+ 6 16.Kd1 3 Qa4+ 28 17.Kc1 9 c5 40 18.d5 36 c4 23 19.d6?! 146 Bf8 3 20.Qd1 70 Qc6 8 21.Qd4 20 Nd7 32 22.Kb1 9 b5 7 23.a4 92 a6 31 24.Be2 6 Nc5! 5 25.Rd1 36 Nd3 10 26.f3 45 Nxf4 33 27.exf4 2 exf3-+ 1 28.Bf1 25 Re4 18 29.Qd5 11 Qxd5 12 30.Rxd5 0 Re1+ 42 31.Ka2 3 f2 1 32.d7 38 Rd8 4 33.h4 13 g6 2 34.Rad1 36 h5 77 35.Kb1 24 Rxd1+? 21 36.Rxd1 1 Bc5 0 37.axb5 88 axb5 0 38.b3 16 Be3 21 39.bxc4 2 bxc4 0 40.f5 31 gxf5 0 41.Bxc4 3 Kg7 9 42.Kc2 12 Bf4 18 43.Rd5= 14 Bg3 8 44.Kd1 7 Bxh4 11 45.Ke2 1 Bg3 48 46.Kf3 31 h4 5 47.Bb5 8 Kg6 11 48.Bd3 25 Kxg5 7 49.Rxf5+ 2 Kg6 0 50.Kg2 7 Kg7 15 51.Rd5 3 Kf6 5 52.Bf5 2 Ke7 17 53.Rc5 10 Kd6 17 54.Rc8 2 Ke7 1 55.Bh3 3 Rxd7 66 56.Bxd7 3 Kxd7 0 57.Rc5 15 Kd6 3 58.Rf5 2 Ke6 1 59.Rf3?? 1 59.Rh5‼ f6 60.Kf1 Kf7 61.Rh7+ Kg6 62.Rh8 Kg7 63.Rh5 Kg6 64.Rh8 f5 65.Rg8+ Kh5 66.Ke2= 59...f5!-+ 15 60.Re3+ 2 Kf6 3 61.Rf3 7 f4?? 35 62.Ra3?? 16 62.Kh3! Ke5 63.Kg2 Ke4 64.Kh3‼ Kf5 65.Kg2 f1Q+ 66.Kxf1 Kg4 67.Ra3 h3 68.Ra8 h2 69.Kg2 f3+ 70.Kh1 f2 71.Ra1 Be5 72.Rf1 Kf3 73.Rxf2+ Kxf2= 62...Kf5?? 25 62...h3+! 63.Kf1 h2 64.Kg2 h1Q+ 65.Kxh1 f1Q# 63.Ra1?? 2 63.Rf3‼ Ke4 63...f1Q+ 64.Rxf1 Ke4 65.Rf3= 64.Kh3= 63...Kg4! 3 64.Rb1 2 h3+ 14 65.Kf1 7 h2 52 66.Kg2 3 f3+-+ 1 67.Kh1 1 Bh4 103 68.Kxh2 7 Bg5 27 69.Rf1 6 Be3 22 70.Kh1 6 Kg3 7 71.Rb1 2 Bd2 2 72.Rf1 6 Be1 3 73.Rxe1 5 fxe1Q# 7 Normal 0–1
  • Start an analysis engine:
  • Try maximizing the board:
  • Use the four cursor keys to replay the game. Make moves to analyse yourself.
  • Press Ctrl-B to rotate the board.
  • Drag the split bars between window panes.
  • Download&Clip PGN/GIF/FEN/QR Codes. Share the game.
  • Games viewed here will automatically be stored in your cloud clipboard (if you are logged in). Use the cloud clipboard also in ChessBase.
  • Create an account to access the games cloud.
WhiteEloWBlackEloBResYearECOEventRnd
Sam Shankland2618Surya Sekhar Ganguly25850–12024D38Venceslav-Rutar Scoring System Match

Game 4: Ganguly 2 - 2 Shankland

Shankland managed to outplay his opponent in the opening and entered a better rook endgame with the black pieces. At one point, he did get a big advantage - but the way to win was not straightforward. After trading one pair of rooks, the game went on to end in an 'equal draw' which meant both players got 2 points.

The final position.

New ...
Open...
Share...
Layout...
Flip Board
Settings
MoveNResultEloPlayers
Replay and check the LiveBook here
1.e4 10 c5 10 2.Nf3 2 d6 1 3.d4 0 cxd4 0 4.Nxd4 1 Nf6 1 5.Nc3 0 a6 0 6.Be3 1 e6 10 7.a3 2 Nc6 9 8.Qe2 30 Nxd4 30 9.Bxd4 1 e5 0 10.Be3 4 Be6 16 11.Bg5 30 Rc8 14 12.Bxf6 55 Qxf6 2 13.Qe3 1 Be7 33 14.0-0-0 4 0-0 40 15.Nd5 15 Qg5 8 16.Kb1 18 Bd8 9 17.Qxg5 9 Bxg5 2 18.h4 1 Bd8 2 19.g3 7 g6 10 20.Bh3 92 Kg7 20 21.f4 30 Bxh3 48 22.Rxh3 0 Rc4 1 23.Nc3?! 43 Ba5 15 24.Rxd6 7 Bxc3 2 25.bxc3 0 exf4 4 26.gxf4 2 Rxe4 1 27.f5 12 Rf4 22 28.fxg6 9 hxg6 11 29.Rd4 10 Rf5 10 30.Rb4 3 b5 8 31.c4 2 Rc8 56 32.cxb5 7 axb5 2 33.Kb2 33 Rfc5 79 34.Rh2 19 Kh6 8 35.Rf4 45 R8c7 7 36.Rhf2 7 f5 33 37.Rb4 62 Kh5 23 38.Rg2 26 R7c6 126 39.Rf4 20 Rc4 6 40.Rgf2 1 R6c5 22 41.Kb3 26 Rc3+ 12 42.Kb4 1 Rc8 94 43.Rg2 25 Rh3 29 44.Rg5+ 19 Kh6 2 45.Rg2 0 Re3 67 46.Rd4 21 Rc4+?! 127 47.Rxc4 2 bxc4 0 48.a4 3 f4= 2 49.Rg4 87 Re4 54 50.a5 67 Kh5 3 51.Rg5+ 1 Kxh4 8 52.Rxg6 2 f3 4 53.Rf6 3 Kg3 2 54.a6 7 f2 8 55.Rf8 31 Re1 53 56.a7 42 Ra1 1 57.Rg8+ 2 Kh2 3 58.Rh8+ 5 Kg2 1 59.Rg8+ 2 Kh2 3 60.Rh8+ 2 Kg2 1 61.Rg8+ 0 Kh2 0 62.Rh8+ 1 Normal ½–½
  • Start an analysis engine:
  • Try maximizing the board:
  • Use the four cursor keys to replay the game. Make moves to analyse yourself.
  • Press Ctrl-B to rotate the board.
  • Drag the split bars between window panes.
  • Download&Clip PGN/GIF/FEN/QR Codes. Share the game.
  • Games viewed here will automatically be stored in your cloud clipboard (if you are logged in). Use the cloud clipboard also in ChessBase.
  • Create an account to access the games cloud.
WhiteEloWBlackEloBResYearECOEventRnd
Surya Sekhar Ganguly2585Sam Shankland2618½–½2024B90Venceslav-Rutar Scoring system match

Day 1 webcast

Find more videos on the ChessBase India YouTube channel


Day 2

Ganguly kept his good form from the last day, and closed the match itself by winning the fifth game -Shankland had no way of coming back in the match.

But the games went on - as the main idea of the match was to test out the Venceslav Rutar scoring system. Game 6 was a draw, and Shankland struck back to score his only win of the match in game 7. The eighth and last game of the match was an absolute rollercoaster, where both players had winning positions at some point, but the game finally ended in a draw.

Ganguly won the match by a 26-11 score!

Game 5: Shankland 0 - 5 Ganguly

Shankland created a very sharp position out of the opening, a Bogo-Indian system. It was a question of who would break through first on the kingside - and it was Ganguly who did it:

Do you see how Black started the kingside attack after 21.Qe2?

Ganguly broke through with the very nice combination 21...Rxf3! 22.Qxf3 Qh2+ 23.Kf1 Ngxf2! 24.Bxf2 Nd2+! to win the white queen.

The Indian GM went on to win comfortably with the black pieces!

New ...
Open...
Share...
Layout...
Flip Board
Settings
MoveNResultEloPlayers
Replay and check the LiveBook here
1.d4 10 d5 10 2.c4 2 e6 1 3.Nf3 1 Nf6 3 4.g3 1 Bb4+ 1 5.Bd2 3 Be7 1 6.Bg2 1 0-0 1 7.0-0 9 Nbd7 4 8.Qc2 15 c6 1 9.a4 11 a5 41 10.Rc1 5 Ne4 19 11.Be1 28 Bd6 9 12.Nc3 4 f5 3 13.Na2 5 Qe7 23 14.Rab1 4 Ndf6 17 15.b4 24 axb4 2 16.Nxb4 8 f4 35 17.Nd3 37 fxg3 3 18.hxg3 3 Ng4 5 19.e3?! 109 19.c5 Bc7 20.Nfe5 Nef6 21.Bh3 19...Qf6 85 20.a5? 49 Qh6! 53 21.Qe2 5 Rxf3! 104 22.Qxf3 215 Qh2+ 2 23.Kf1 1 Ngxf2! 0 24.Bxf2 2 Nd2+ 11 25.Ke2 1 Nxf3 0 26.Bxf3-+ 5 Qh6 34 27.Be1 91 Qh2+ 22 28.Bf2 2 Qh6 1 29.Ra1 25 Bd7 49 30.c5 130 Bc7 3 31.Rcb1 1 Bc8 17 32.Rh1 19 Qg6 3 33.a6 82 bxa6 12 34.Rh4 47 a5 6 35.Kd2 8 Ba6 4 36.Be2 11 Rf8 3 37.Be1 7 Bb5 23 38.Rg4 8 Qf5 4 39.Rh4 4 a4 2 40.Ra3 22 Ba5+ 9 41.Kd1 3 Bxe1 5 42.Kxe1 4 Bxd3 4 Normal 0–1
  • Start an analysis engine:
  • Try maximizing the board:
  • Use the four cursor keys to replay the game. Make moves to analyse yourself.
  • Press Ctrl-B to rotate the board.
  • Drag the split bars between window panes.
  • Download&Clip PGN/GIF/FEN/QR Codes. Share the game.
  • Games viewed here will automatically be stored in your cloud clipboard (if you are logged in). Use the cloud clipboard also in ChessBase.
  • Create an account to access the games cloud.
WhiteEloWBlackEloBResYearECOEventRnd
Sam Shankland2618Surya Sekhar Ganguly25850–12024D30Venceslav Rutar Scoring System Match

Game 6: Ganguly 2 - 2 Shankland

This game was more or less a stable draw, but with a big missed chance in the opening. See if you can find it:

Ganguly played 14.Na5? which is a big mistake. Shankland replied by 14...Nd4 missing the refutation - can you find the best move for Black?

New ...
Open...
Share...
Layout...
Flip Board
Settings
MoveNResultEloPlayers
Replay and check the LiveBook here
1.e4 10 c5 10 2.Nf3 2 d6 0 3.d4 1 cxd4 1 4.Nxd4 0 Nf6 0 5.Nc3 1 a6 1 6.h3 1 g6 2 7.g4 50 Bg7 3 8.Be3 15 0-0 5 9.Bg2 6 Nc6 35 10.Qe2 17 Nxe4 156 11.Nxc6 3 Nxc3 2 12.Nxd8 1 Nxe2 1 13.Nxb7 0 Rb8 33 14.Na5? 43 Nd4? 11 14...Nc3! 15.b3 Bd7 16.0-0 Rfe8-+ 15.0-0-0 44 Rb5 138 16.Bxd4 5 Rxa5 1 17.Bxg7 4 Kxg7= 2 18.a3 0 h5 23 19.Rd4 41 Be6 6 20.Bf3 12 hxg4 4 21.hxg4 0 Rc8 19 22.Kd2 22 Rac5 13 23.c3 8 a5 14 24.Rc1 14 Bb3 19 25.Bd1 4 Bxd1 28 26.Rxd1 0 d5 16 27.Re1 31 e6 5 28.Re3 1 g5 10 29.b4 7 axb4 6 30.axb4 12 R5c6 10 31.f4 14 Rc4 90 32.fxg5 39 Rxd4+ 4 33.cxd4 0 Rc4 1 34.Rb3 1 Rxd4+ 2 35.Ke2 55 Rxg4 36 36.b5 2 Rc4 3 37.b6 2 Rc8 2 38.b7 2 Rb8 1 39.Kf3 3 Kg6 16 40.Kf4 4 f6 8 41.gxf6 1 Kxf6 1 42.Rb6 1 Ke7 50 43.Ke5 1 Kd7 1 44.Rxe6 3 Rxb7 3 45.Kxd5 2 Rb5+ 1 46.Kc4 1 Kxe6 1 47.Kxb5 6 Normal ½–½
  • Start an analysis engine:
  • Try maximizing the board:
  • Use the four cursor keys to replay the game. Make moves to analyse yourself.
  • Press Ctrl-B to rotate the board.
  • Drag the split bars between window panes.
  • Download&Clip PGN/GIF/FEN/QR Codes. Share the game.
  • Games viewed here will automatically be stored in your cloud clipboard (if you are logged in). Use the cloud clipboard also in ChessBase.
  • Create an account to access the games cloud.
WhiteEloWBlackEloBResYearECOEventRnd
Surya Sekhar Ganguly2585Sam Shankland2618½–½2024B90Venceslav Rutar Scoring System

Game 7: Shankland 5 - 0 Ganguly

This was the best game of the match for Shankland, and the only game he won. He outplayed his opponent right from the opening, and scored a comfortable win.

The start of the queen endgame.

New ...
Open...
Share...
Layout...
Flip Board
Settings
MoveNResultEloPlayers
Replay and check the LiveBook here
1.d4 10 d5 10 2.c4 3 e6 2 3.Nf3 0 Nf6 2 4.g3 1 Bb4+ 1 5.Bd2 1 Be7 1 6.Bg2 1 0-0 1 7.0-0 1 Nbd7 2 8.Qc2 2 c6 2 9.a4 1 a5 25 10.Rc1 2 Bb4 15 11.Bxb4 31 axb4 2 12.Nbd2 1 Qe7 22 13.e4 81 Nxe4 37 14.Nxe4 3 dxe4 0 15.Qxe4 2 c5 2 16.Qe3 99 cxd4 23 17.Nxd4 3 Nc5?! 0 18.b3 39 Re8 67 19.Rd1± 19 Bd7 6 20.Nc2 9 Bc6 112 21.Bxc6 127 bxc6 0 22.Nxb4? 1 Nxa4 1 23.Nxc6 16 Qb7 43 24.Rxa4 158 Rxa4 4 25.Nd8!+- 4 Qa8 41 26.bxa4 3 Rxd8 0 27.Rxd8+ 2 Qxd8 0 28.Qc5 65 Qd1+ 18 29.Kg2 1 h5 0 30.a5 22 h4 9 31.Qc6 36 h3+ 18 32.Kxh3 2 Qf1+ 1 33.Qg2 6 Qxc4 1 34.Qa8+ 1 Kh7 1 35.Kg2 1 e5 8 36.a6 109 e4 2 37.Qb7 39 Qd3 18 38.Qxf7 4 Qxa6 1 39.Qf5+ 5 Kg8 2 40.Qxe4 1 Qa2 22 41.h4 2 Qb2 6 42.g4 6 Kh8 4 43.Kg3 9 Qc3+ 3 44.Qe3 3 Qc7+ 2 45.f4 1 Qb7 3 46.h5 5 Qh1 13 47.f5 35 Kh7 5 48.g5 8 Qa8 24 49.g6+ 14 Kh8 6 50.h6 21 Qb8+ 1 51.Kg4 10 Qd8 64 52.hxg7+ 28 Kxg7 2 53.Qc3+ 1 Kg8 14 54.Qb3+ 2 Kh8 31 55.Qh3+ 2 Kg7 1 56.Qh7+ 0 Kf8 1 57.Qf7# 6 Normal 1–0
  • Start an analysis engine:
  • Try maximizing the board:
  • Use the four cursor keys to replay the game. Make moves to analyse yourself.
  • Press Ctrl-B to rotate the board.
  • Drag the split bars between window panes.
  • Download&Clip PGN/GIF/FEN/QR Codes. Share the game.
  • Games viewed here will automatically be stored in your cloud clipboard (if you are logged in). Use the cloud clipboard also in ChessBase.
  • Create an account to access the games cloud.
WhiteEloWBlackEloBResYearECOEventRnd
Sam Shankland2618Surya Sekhar Ganguly25851–02024D30Venceslav Rutar Scoring System Match

Game 8: Ganguly 2 - 2 Shankland

This was an up-and-down game with many chances for both sides. Ganguly got a completely winning position in the rook endgame, but made an unfortunate blunder. Can you spot the problem with this?

Position after 71.Ke3?. Do you see White's mistake and how Black drew the game?

New ...
Open...
Share...
Layout...
Flip Board
Settings
MoveNResultEloPlayers
Replay and check the LiveBook here
1.e4 10 c5 10 2.Nf3 9 d6 1 3.d4 2 cxd4 1 4.Nxd4 0 Nf6 1 5.Nc3 0 a6 0 6.Be3 1 e5 2 7.Nb3 3 Be6 5 8.h3 3 Be7 11 9.g4 3 0-0 8 10.g5 14 Nfd7 13 11.h4 6 Nb6 93 12.Bxb6 25 Qxb6 2 13.Nd5 0 Bxd5 137 14.Qxd5 0 Nd7 8 15.Bh3 53 Rad8 32 16.0-0-0 24 g6 66 17.Bxd7 25 Rxd7 1 18.Rd2 1 Rc7 12 19.Kb1 8 Kg7 26 20.a3 30 Qc6 63 21.Qd3 26 Qc4 24 22.Qe3 1 Qe6 53 23.Nc1 79 Rfc8?! 45 24.f3!± 12 b5 34 25.h5 3 Kg8 7 26.Rdh2 22 Bd8 32 27.Nd3?! 12 a5 9 28.f4 58 exf4 37 29.Nxf4 4 Bxg5 24 30.Nxe6 59 Bxe3 2 31.Nxc7 0 Rxc7= 0 32.Rd1 44 Bf4 10 33.Rf2 2 Be5 17 34.h6 1 Kf8 96 35.Rd5 4 Rb7 9 36.Rf3 5 a4 18 37.c3 36 Ke7 3 38.Kc2 2 Ke6 5 39.Rd1 9 g5 10 40.Rg1 11 f6 1 41.Kd3 7 Rb8 11 42.Ke2 23 Rg8 24 43.Rg4 4 Kf7 6 44.Rh3 26 Rc8 7 45.Rg1 11 Rc4 14 46.Kd3 16 Ke6 8 47.Rf3 5 d5 32 48.exd5+ 24 Kxd5 1 49.Rgf1 150 Ke6 17 50.Re3 14 Rh4 51 51.Re4? 2 Rxh6-+ 1 52.Rb4 1 Rg6? 8 53.Rxb5 2 g4 6 54.Rb6+ 1 Kd5= 10 55.b4 15 axb3 3 56.Rb1 30 Rh6 38 57.c4+ 2 Kc5 1 58.Rb5+ 5 Kd6 5 59.R1xb3 30 Ke6 8 60.Rb6+ 35 Kf5 2 61.c5 1 g3 6 62.Rb1 11 Kg4 12 63.R6b4+ 34 Kg5 4 64.c6 4 Rh3 4 65.Rg1 61 Kf5 8 66.a4 46 h5 6 67.a5 1 Rh2? 2 68.Rb5!+- 21 Ke6 5 69.Rxe5+ 6 fxe5 2 70.Rc1 2 e4+ 13 71.Ke3?? 12 71.Kxe4 Rh4+ 72.Kf3+- 71...g2 6 72.c7 1 g1Q+ 1 73.Rxg1 6 Rc2= 1 74.Rg5 38 Rxc7 2 75.Rxh5 2 Rc4 5 76.Kf4 15 Kd6 2 77.a6 4 Ra4 3 78.a7 7 Kc6 1 79.Re5 4 Rxa7 3 80.Kxe4 1 Rd7 4 81.Re6+ 2 Rd6 0 82.Rxd6+ 1 Kxd6 6 Normal ½–½
  • Start an analysis engine:
  • Try maximizing the board:
  • Use the four cursor keys to replay the game. Make moves to analyse yourself.
  • Press Ctrl-B to rotate the board.
  • Drag the split bars between window panes.
  • Download&Clip PGN/GIF/FEN/QR Codes. Share the game.
  • Games viewed here will automatically be stored in your cloud clipboard (if you are logged in). Use the cloud clipboard also in ChessBase.
  • Create an account to access the games cloud.
WhiteEloWBlackEloBResYearECOEventRnd
Surya Sekhar Ganguly2585Sam Shankland2618½–½2024B90Venceslav Rutar Scoring System

Day 2 webcast

Find more videos on the ChessBase India YouTube channel


What was so special about this event?

The scoring system. Today, there are countless variations of chess. This is the first time that any scoring system has been developed which focuses on draws. The traditional scoring system divides the points equally between the two players. This rule has been followed for many centuries. Draws are an integral part of chess, and we cannot eliminate them ever. While no one can really convince the players to fight for a win, one person decided to change the rules. He created such rules that would make players fight for a win.

If they can't win the game, change the rules!

The traditional scoring system with 1 point (to the winner), ½ point (to both the players), and 0 points (to the loser) is replaced by a system with 5 possibilities.

Outcome Points Abbreviation
Win 5 W
Favoured Draw 3 F
Equal Draw 2 E
Disfavoured Draw 1 D
Loss 0 L

Points for the winner and loser are self-explanatory. But, when the game is declared as a draw, the tournament director will count all the pieces on the board. The material balance will be calculated by adding values as follows:

Piece Points
Pawn 1
Knight 3
Bishop 3
Rook 5
Queen 9

The player who has more pieces on the board (material advantage) will get 3 points (favoured draw) and the other player will get 1 point (disfavoured draw). If the material advantage is the same for both players, then both will get 2 points.

Let's see some draw scenarios to understand this better:

Scenario Result
Rook against Bishop Favoured Draw (5 vs 3)
Rook against Bishop + Pawn Favoured Draw (5 vs 4)
Rook against Bishop + 2 Pawns Equal Draw (5 vs 5)
Rook against Bishop + 3 Pawns Firstly, why will the player accept the draw?

This system does not change the following possibilities that result in a draw:

  • Agreement between players
  • Bare kings
  • Stalemate
  • 3-fold repetition
  • 50 reversible moves in a row

What about the "timeout vs insufficient material"?

Let's consider two scenarios to understand this.

  1. Player A has only one bishop and Player B has only one knight. If player A flags, then he will get 1 point (disfavoured draw) because he ran out of time and player B will get 2 points (equal draw) because of equal material.
  2. Player C has one knight and Player D has a king only. If player C flags, then he will get 1 point (disfavoured draw) because he ran out of time and player D will also get 1 point (disfavoured draw) because of insufficient material.

Why this system?

If we take a closer look at the drawn games, we will notice that sometimes giving half a point to both players appears unfair. A draw might be unfair in the following two situations:

  1. Sometimes a player might have a clear advantage on the board with material advantage, but still end up in a stalemate / 3-fold repetition situation.
  2. A player with a winning position might run out of time but still draw due to insufficient material on the opponent's side. This can be unfair to the player having a winning position.

This scoring system tries to bring justice in such unjust situations. We must accept that all draws are not equal.


Links


ChessBase India is currently the biggest chess news portal and chess software distributor in India. We have daily reports about tournaments in India, profiles of the best talents and information about players performing admirably at the international level. Our motto is “Powering Chess in India”. Apart from news, we provide all the services that are required to ease the life of a chess player.

We use cookies and comparable technologies to provide certain functions, to improve the user experience and to offer interest-oriented content. Depending on their intended use, analysis cookies and marketing cookies may be used in addition to technically required cookies. Here you can make detailed settings or revoke your consent (if necessary partially) with effect for the future. Further information can be found in our data protection declaration.