Too fast, too strong: Carlsen's Singapore simul

by Junior Tay
10/9/2017 – The October 6th, 2017, was a great day for Singapore chess. Thanks to the efforts of Norwegian Business Association Singapore, World Champion Magnus Carlsen visited the country for a simul against 16 players that was greatly enjoyed and appreciated by all the chess lovers of Singapore. The opposition that Magnus faced was not easy. Some players were rank amateurs, but there were also seasoned experts, with six-time National champion IM Kevin Goh Wei Ming (rated 2461!) being one of the participants. But Magnus showed absolutely no mercy; he cleaned up the field with a 16-0 score in little over an hour! | Pictured: Esther Koh (Business Development Director, Zenitant Holdings), Magnus Carlsen, and Michelle Tay (Director, Hauterobe Pte Ltd) | Photo: Junior Tay

Winning starts with what you know
The new version 18 offers completely new possibilities for chess training and analysis: playing style analysis, search for strategic themes, access to 6 billion Lichess games, player preparation by matching Lichess games, download Chess.com games with built-in API, built-in cloud engine and much more.

Astounding speed and precision

In a move greatly appreciated by Singaporean chess fans, Norwegian Business Association Singapore (NBAS) and Simonsen Vogt Wiig law firm organized a simultaneous chess match for 16 players to face the World Champion at the Norwegian Ambassador’s residence on October 6th. The organizers also roped in the support of the Singapore Chess Federation to supply the beautiful wooden Staunton sets for the occasion. Only 16 players could take the seats to face the World champion but the place was jam-packed with Norwegian businesspeople and Singaporean chess fanatics, all joining in the occasion to witness the maestro at work.

Carlsen arriving

Photo: Andrey Terekhov

Prior to Magnus’ arrival, the emcee of the event, Mr Hakon Bruasket Kjel (Senior VP, Telenor Group) remarked to me that it is an honour for them to host someone of Magnus’ stature, and they are glad to create this avenue for local fans to get close to the World champion as well. Well, the serious chess fans operated strategically too, placing themselves at the doorway to ‘ambush’ Magnus upon his entrance and they were rewarded for their strong positional sense with autographs as well as a beaming Magnus pic.

Hakon opened the event by introducing the players who were about to get the game of their lives:

  1. Anders Hellum, Consultant and Global Leader – The Gap Partnership
  2. Tom Hellebø. CEO, The Edge Group (Singapore)
  3. Per Fredrik Aamot, Intern, Norwegian Embassy
  4. Magnus Grimland, NBAS board member and co-founder of Zalora
  5. Are Glørensen, Director, Tronrud Engineering Pte Ltd
  6. William Klippgen, Co-founder of price comparison portal Zoomit.com
  7. Morthen Winther, Partner Simonson Vogt Wiig
  8. John Lee Say Siong, representing Singapore Chess Federation
  9. NM Olimpiu Urcan, Chess Historian/Author, Top Chess Journalist on Twitter
  10. IM Kevin Goh Wei Ming, 6 time Singapore champion, CFO Lucence Diagnostics, (Elo 2461!!)
  11. Dr Lee Chien Earn, CEO Changi General Hospital
  12. Pok Wern Jian, former Malaysian national player, Teacher I/C chess in National Junior Colelge
  13. Carleton Lim, founder Fixitchess, grandson of Singapore’s chess doyen Professor Lim Kok Ann
  14. Fridtjof Berge, Associate, Mc Kinsey and Company
  15. Joshua Lim Geok Hock, Head of Trading East, Shell LNG
  16. Alexander Boe, Trading Partner, Telenor

Photo: Junior Tay

Espen Agdestein

One very much appreciated innovation was Team Carlsen’s FM Espen Agdestein’s running commentary to the audience on how each player was doing every few moves.

Soon, it became apparent that Olimpiu, Kevin, Chien Earn and Joshua were putting up strong resistance, especially, Kevin who was assessed to be giving Magnus an interesting fight. Espen also helpfully explained to the audience that typically, a player of Kevin’s stature (a 2461 rated IM) would not be participating in such a simul exhibition but Magnus loves a challenge so there you have it. Before the game, Kevin remarked in jest that he would be facing a third member of the Norwegian Olympiad team, having fought GMs Simen Agdestein and GM Aryan Tari to draws only a month ago. So can he keep ‘Team Norway’ at bay?

As I expected (having witnessed how Magnus dealt with 11 players — including two IMs — in a 2015 Chess.com online simul) Magnus played almost instantly on each board, moving from board to board with amazing speed. Clearly, the players were placed under tremendous pressure (how does the dude think so fast?) having to deal with his speedy moves.

Within a hour and a quarter, all 16 opponents were routed, though Dr Lee Chien Earn put up great resistance.

Photo: Andrey Terekhov

Four players who gave Magnus the maximum resistance | Photo: Andrey Terekhov

Dr Lee Chien Earn (father of FM Lee Qing Aun) was the last opponent to lay down the arms. Just as we thought it was the end of a great show, Magnus went one better by explaining in detail about how the games went for the stronger opponents he faced! Here’s a transcription of what Magnus commented and the games he was commenting about. (You can replay all games below.)

Magnus Carlsen vs IM Kevin Goh

"Against Kevin Goh, I was probably a bit worse out of the opening. I think he made a crucial mistake by putting his rook on e8, and had Kevin not lost a pawn, he would be In very good shape". He went on to analyse with Kevin in greater detail as seen in the following game annotated by the latter below.

Magnus Carlsen vs NM Olimpiu Urcan

"I also noticed that Olimpiu played the same opening I recently played against Kasimdzhanov. I assumed it was …..(Olimpiu interjected at this point “A bit of trolling?” amid laughter) part of a joke. Anyway, this game I solved this problem of the wayward rook and it is very difficult for Black to improve his position".

Carlsen vs Dr Lee Chien Earn

"I thought I had some advantage from the opening but he defended very stoutly with Knight on e6 and Knight on f6 and I couldn’t for the life of me see how to make progress but eventually I got the pawns moving and I think he played a bit too fast. At several points, it was possible to go for counterplay with ….c4 but I assume especially in a simul, you want to hold and not rock the boat unnecessarily".
 
Magnus even went to demonstrate to the audience ‘a funny position’, a cute stalemate position for Earn Chien, assuming the latter could get rid of his major pieces (not possible, according to Magnus, to the laughter of the audience).

Photo: Junior Tay

Carlsen vs Joshua Lim

Carlsen playing simul

Epsen remarked that Magnus had a nice finish against Joshua Lim and the World Champion remarked “Yes, I thought at some point you played very well with the regrouping …Rc8, …Bd7, …Qd8, …Ne8 so I sort of had to take action with f4 but maybe you could have played …Nd6 a bit earlier on. If I take on e5, my e4-pawn is hanging as counterplay. Maybe you should go for …e5 at some point to give up a pawn and at least activate the pieces, advance the pawns in front of my king and it might be exposed”.

"In general, I think several of the players were giving too much respect, so maybe next time play a little more aggressively. It’s not easy to strike the right balance".

 
New ...
Open...
Share...
Layout...
Flip Board
Settings
MoveNResultEloPlayers
Replay and check the LiveBook here
It was a tremendous privilege and honor to have the opportunity to face the reigning World Champion, Magnus Carlsen, even if it was only a simul exhibition. Before the game, almost all the chess friends that I spoke to said that there is no point preparing against the guy - he simply plays everything under the sun as a quick search on Megadatabase will tell you. Still, I checked a few trendy lines that I thought Magnus might try and by sheer luck, one of them actually appeared over the board... 1.c4 Nf6 This was an attempt to transpose to Anti-Grunfeld lines which may arise after 2.Nf3 g6. 1...e6 2.Nc3 , 1...g6 2.e4 and 1...c5 were other possible options. 2.Nc3 e5 3.e3 True to his style, Magnus cannot be bothered to go into the absolute mainstream stuff. This was not a difficult move to predict given that he has played 1.e3 at the Baku Olympiad against a reasonably strong Grandmaster! A recent game I played with another strong Norwegian player continued (by transposition) 3.Nf3 Nc6 4.g3 d5 5.cxd5 Nxd5 6.Bg2 Bc5 A trendy line popularised by Fabiano Caruana 7.0-0 0-0 8.d3 Bb6 9.Bd2 Bg4 10.Na4 Qd6 11.Rc1 Rad8 and the game Tari - Goh, Barcelona 2017 eventually ended peacefully. 3...Bb4 3...Nc6 was my main preparation but here, Magnus had played 4.g4!? against MVL during one of the Grand Chess Tours, winning in brilliant style. I see absolutely no reason why I should try to defend a position that MVL couldn't.... 4.Nge2 0-0 5.a3 Be7 6.Ng3 My very brief preparation continued 6.d4 exd4 7.Qxd4 (Controlling the d5 break is logical) 7.Nxd4 d5 leads to comfortable equality. 7...c6! 7...Nc6 is an automatic move but after 8.Qd1 , Black is running the risk of entering a slightly passive middlegame since the ...d5 break will be almost impossible to achieve. 8.Nf4 Na6!? with interesting play. 6...c6 6...d5 was also possible and could have been a slightly smarter choice since I ended up taking on d5 with the knight anyway. 7.cxd5 Nxd5 8.Qc2 Be6 8...c5 9.Bc4 Nc7!? 9.Be2 9.Nf5 Bf6 is fine for Black 9...c5 and Black has equalised with chances of fighting for the initiative 7.d4 After the game, Magnus and I briefly discussed 7.Nf5 d5 8.Nxe7+ Qxe7 9.d4 exd4 10.Qxd4 Rd8 and now the threat of ...c6-c5 gives Black good play in the centre. 7...exd4 8.exd4 d5 9.cxd5 Right around this moment, the guy sitting next to me was checkmated with Qd1-h5. I then realised that this was going to be a more difficult evening than expected... Re8!? 9...Nxd5 10.Bd3 Re8 11.0-0 Be6 was maybe also fine for Black but I thought that I should cleverly try to prevent Bd3 if I could. Magnus's next move took me, and a lot of other strong players by surprise. 10.Bd3!? Ignoring the discovered check. Regardless of the objective strength of the move, many players, including former National Champion and Olympian IM Hsu Li Yang, considered this to be remarkable especially given that this was played under simul conditions. 10.dxc6 was my main worry, where I calculated Nxc6 10...Bc5+ 11.Be3 Bxd4 12.cxb7 Bxb7 was also possible but I didn't really believe that such a dream could materialise. 11.Be3 Ng4 followed by vague ideas of ...Bf6 or ...Bg5. 10...Bxa3+ 11.Nge2 Bf8 It was difficult for me to decide an appropriate retreat square for my bishop. 11...Bb4 is one of the engine's top choices, but I didn't see what the bishop was doing on a square which my queen's knight wanted for herself. 11...Bd6 is logical but it reduces my control over the d5 square while 11...Be7 has the idea of regrouping with ..Nd5 and . .Bf6 but it also temporarily blocks the e-file. In the end, it was a matter of weighing the various pros and cons. 12.dxc6 Nxc6 13.0-0 Nb4 14.Bb1 Bg4?! A natural but pseudo active move. On hindsight, 14...Be6!? with the idea 15.Bg5 Bc4 was strategically desirable especially since 16.Ne4 can be met by Be7 followed by exchanges. 15.Bg5 15.f3?! Be6 was my intention but Magnus was never going to give away squares without something concrete in return. 15...Qb6 16.Qd2 Bxe2 An important decision but perhaps overtly hasty. I should also add that Magnus graciously allowed me to "pass" when I asked for a bit more time at this juncture. Taking a breather with 16...a6! would have solved a lot of my problems but I naively wanted to play concretely at every juncture. 17.Nxe2 Ne4 18.Bxe4 Rxe4 19.Be3 Nd5? The first real mistake of the game, allowing Magnus to improve his pawn structure. It was really important to play 19...a6 now as it will soon be clear. 20.Nc3 Nxe3 I didn't like 20...Nxc3 21.bxc3 Having said that, the position after a5!? might be better for White but Black retains a sliver of counterplay, which is more than what he got in the game. 21.fxe3 Re6? Not the best square for the rook, the reason to which will be explained in the note to White's next move. 21...Ree8 with the idea 22.Qf2 Qe6 was slightly better for White. 22.Qd3?! To my horror, I realised that my original intention of meeting 22.Qf2 with Rf6?? could be met by 23.Nd5! Rxf2 24.Nxb6 Rxf1+ 25.Kxf1 Re8 26.Rxa7 Rxe3 27.Ra8! and White wins. Maybe this was what Magnus missed. Instead, I was probably going to continue 22.Qf2 f6 23.Nd5 Qc6 24.Qf3 Rd8 25.e4 with an unpleasant position but at least Black is still alive. 22...Rae8? A horrendous blunder, perhaps induced by the imposing speed of the World Champion or maybe the 3 glasses of wine just before the game? 22...Rd8! was of course my original intention, when there is still everything to play for. 23.Nd5 Qd6 24.Qf5! Winning a pawn by force. Not an ideal situation against a World Champion best known for his technical play. Qd7 It wasn't pleasant to miss a simple 2-mover but there was no need to capitulate. 24...f6 25.Rxa7 Qc6! with the idea of playing ..Rd6 and ..Qc2 would have given Black some counterplay. I have to admit that this counter-intuitive manoeuvre was machine-inspired and I would probably have missed even with a bit more time on the clock. 25.Rxa7 Rd6 26.Qxd7 Rxd7 27.Ra5! Magnus displays his flawless conversion technique from this juncture. As Olimpiu Urcan succintly puts it, I was about to be subjected to severe medieval torture.... Red8 28.Nc3 Re8 29.Rf3 Rc8 30.Rb5 g6 31.g4! stopping ..f7-f5 and keeping absolute control on the kingside. Be7 32.Kf2 Ra8 33.Ke2 Kg7 34.Kd3 Ra1 35.h3 h6 36.e4 Rg1 37.e5 Re1 38.Nd5 Bg5 39.Kc4 Bd2 40.Rfb3 Rc1+ 41.Kd3 Bg5 42.Nc3 Rh1 43.Rxb7 Rxh3+ 44.Kc4 Rd8 45.Ne4 And with his knight jumping to d6, my kingside stymied by a solitary pawn on g4, and with his passed pawns about to be set in motion, I've seen enough. 1–0
  • Start an analysis engine:
  • Try maximizing the board:
  • Use the four cursor keys to replay the game. Make moves to analyse yourself.
  • Press Ctrl-B to rotate the board.
  • Drag the split bars between window panes.
  • Download&Clip PGN/GIF/FEN/QR Codes. Share the game.
  • Games viewed here will automatically be stored in your cloud clipboard (if you are logged in). Use the cloud clipboard also in ChessBase.
  • Create an account to access the games cloud.
WhiteEloWBlackEloBResYearECOEventRnd
Magnus Carlsen-Goh Wei Ming,K-1–02017A22Simultaneous Exhibition
Carlsen,M-Urcan,O-1–02017B08Simultaneous Exhibition
Carlsen,M-Lee,C-1–02017C77Simultaneous Exhibition
Carlsen,M-Lim,J-1–02017A55Simultaneous Exhibition

Scarcely any world champion has managed to captivate chess lovers to the extent Carlsen has. The enormously talented Norwegian hasn't been systematically trained within the structures of a major chess-playing nation such as Russia, the Ukraine or China.

And with that, the crowd showed their appreciation with much applause. What more can you ask for, a masterclass display, a running commentary during the game and patient post game analysis by the world champion himself! As IM Hsu Li Yang remarked, after the games, Magnus was also very generous with his time after the game with the audience, signing autographs and taking pictures with fans for a long time. A really successful event for which we must really thank NBAS, Team Norway and Simonsen Vogt Wiig for organizing and our host, Norway's Ambassador Designate to Singapore, Ms Anita Nergaard!

Video by Junior Tay

Originally published on Junior Tay's blog and reproduced here with his permission.

Links


A chess author, editor and coach for the past three years after being a school teacher for 17 years, Tay is a former National Rapid and Cairnhill Open Champion and represented Singapore in international events including the Asian Team Championships.

Discuss

Rules for reader comments

 
 

Not registered yet? Register

We use cookies and comparable technologies to provide certain functions, to improve the user experience and to offer interest-oriented content. Depending on their intended use, analysis cookies and marketing cookies may be used in addition to technically required cookies. Here you can make detailed settings or revoke your consent (if necessary partially) with effect for the future. Further information can be found in our data protection declaration.