Russian Women's National Team Excluded
The Russia women, reigning Women’s Champions in the previous two
Olympiads, are set to miss this year's Olympiad in Tromsø due to
the failure of the Russian Chess Federation to submit their team line-up
before the deadline set by FIDE. The World Chess Federation has protested
and even considered canceling the Olympiad, with the Russian Chess Federation
threatening to take the Olympiad organisers to court.
The mighty Russian team won gold in both 2010
and 2012
Needless to say, this has created enormous turmoil and consternation in
the chess community, and the question is how this happened and why. The
regulations for registering a team in the Olympiad, including the deadlines,
are neither new, nor convoluted. As such, the Russian Chess Federation has
explained that in full accordance with paragraph 3.6.1 of the Chess Olympiad
regulations, it had promptly sent a request for participation of men and
women's national teams – before April 1, 2014. However, this is
but the first, albeit necessary, step to include a team in the event.
The next step, whose deadline was on June 1st, is to send the organizers
the list of players and delegation members who are to be representing the
nation. This was done in full for the Russian Men's team, but not the
Women's, and on July 16, the Chess Olympiad organizers informed the
Russian Chess Federation that for missing the June 1st deadline to send
the list, the Women's team was out.
The open letter announcing the decision
On its end, the Russian Chess Federation has drawn attention to the fact
that there are no penalties provided for failing to comply with paragraph
3.6.1. Moreover, paragraph 3.7.2 states that late inscriptions for players
or delegation members is allowed, up to 20 hours before the start of the
event. In this case, a late charge of 100 Euros is applied to each such
player or delegation member. It is not immediately clear whether the late
inscription mentioned is to replace a player as opposed to just adding a
new one.
Furthermore, on July 7, 2014, the organizing committee billed the RCF for
the registration of ten players, two attendants, the two team captains,
two coaches and the head of delegation (a total of seventeen people) for
the amount of 13,600 Euros. This bill was promptly paid for by the Russian
Chess Federation and was received by the organizers. As a result of this,
the RCF claims that the organizing committee has no legal grounds to ban
the Russian Women's team from participating in the Olympics in Tromsø.
In Bergamo at the ACP Golden Classic tournament, Israel Gelfer, FIDE Vice
President, had strong words on the incident:
In the video FIDE Vice President Israel Gelfer states:
"The organisers of Tromsø are very disappointing, they are
causing a lot of problems to FIDE and to the whole world of chess. Unfortunately
the Organizing Committee is influenced by people who are working for Garry
Kasparov; they are using it for their election purposes; they are denying
visas for our people, they are denying invitations from federations; they
are not respecting the FIDE President's decisions which is very clear
according to regulations. FIDE has to consider now very, very strict or
strong measures against them. We are still considering what to do. But
we are very disappointed at their behavior, and from the way they are
handling all the preparations."
The accusation of Garry Kasparov is both quite serious, and equally strange.
After all, what could the former World Champion possibly gain by preventing
the Russian Women's team from competing? In effect, when we asked the
Kasparov Campaign about the statement they seemed quite baffled and asked
us in return to name possible grounds for Kasparov's involvement. Furthermore
they invited us to consider why the Russian Chess Federation had missed
the deadline – which we have done, further below.
The reference to the lack of respect for the FIDE President's decisions,
stems from article 6.1 in the regulations that grants the FIDE President
the right to make the final decision on all matters relating to the Olympics
as a whole. This point is one the Norwegian organizers take issue with,
as stated in the open letter:
If the Fide President is of the opinion that the OR point 6.1 gives
him the general power to change regulations singlehandedly three weeks before
the Olympiad takes place, we strongly object. Even more, we object to such
an interpretation when the purpose is to secure participation from a team
coming from his own federation.
RCF has announced its readiness to appeal the organizing committee's
decision in court.
The organizers all signed the open letter, which we are told was done after
a unanimous vote had been taken, reached after month-long conversations
with the RCF, with FIDE, and internally. The letter to FIDE makes no mention
of the Russian women's team (other than in the context of FIDE pressuring
them about it), saying only all teams that didn't make the deadline can't
play. Clearly no exceptions can be made for a single major federation.
In the video interview above Gelfer goes on to say:
"We don't know yet, because just now we were informed that they
refused several federations which are late in registration, in spite of
the President accepting them – according to the Olympiad regulations
Article 6.1 it lies in the hands of the FIDE President – they ignored
his letters, and FIDE is now considering very strong matters – legal
matters. I would even have recommended to cancel the Olympiad, if it is
necessary, because their behaviour is unacceptable."
The Lagno connection
The question that comes to mind is of course why the Russian Chess Federation
allowed the deadline to pass without registering the women's team, while
the men's team was sent in well in time. Well, it's an open secret
that the Russians have been trying to strengthen their female squad with
GM Kateryna Lagno, currently number seven in the world, ahead of any Russian
women. Katya, however, hails from Ukraine, and the Chess Federation of that
country registered
a protest with FIDE:
The Ukrainian Chess Federation became aware of the fact that the Russian
Chess Federation has made an illegal attempt to register the Ukrainian
chess player Ms. Lagno for participation in 2014 Chess Olympiad in Tromso
as a member of the Russian Chess Federation team. Moreover, we are cognizant
of the pressure exercised by the Executive Director of FIDE Mr. Freeman
in this regard, favoring the extension of the deadline [July 1 2014] to
enable such a registration.
As of today Kateryna Lagno is an official member of the Ukrainian Chess
Federation. Following all FIDE procedures and time schedules Ms. Lagno
has been duly included into the Ukrainian national team for participation
in the 2014 Chess Olympiad in Tromso. There is no legal ground for transferring
of Ms. Lagno from the Ukrainian Chess Federation to any other federation.
The matter is under consideration with the status quo retained.
Kateryna Lagno, a former child
prodigy, won a bronze medal with the Ukrainian team at the Istanbul
Olympiad. She was briefly
married to French GM Robert Fontaine, moved to Russia after the breakup
and applied for membership in the RCF. "I wish to stress that my changing
federations is in no way connected to the political situation in Ukraine,"
she said, "and I don't have and have ever had any conflicts with the Ukrainian
Chess Federation. No one was pushing or pulling me, and the fact that I
want to change my federation, together with changing my residence, has been
known for a year." Her
transfer has been pushed through, with a €20,000 compensation for
the Ukrainian Chess Federation and a €5,000 for FIDE. Kateryna is is
eligible to participate under the new flag starting from July 12, 2014.
QED.
The urgency of Lagno's inclusion in the Russian Women's team is
highlighted by fact that two of the strongest Russian females, GMs Nadezhda
and Tatiana Kosintseva, refuse
to play on the team. As far as we know they are not available for the
Tromsø Olympiad.
Important
links
