Qatar 2015 Rd1: Surprises, upsets – what a start!

by Albert Silver
12/20/2015 – In a massive open with many of the best players in the world, upsets are expected, but even the most jaded viewers were left gawking in round one. The first and foremost was Magnus Carlsen held to a draw with white by IM Nino Batsiashvili. While that stood out, so did 11-year-old Abdusattorov’s draw against GM Sam Shankland. Express report with all results and games.

ChessBase 14 Download ChessBase 14 Download

Everyone uses ChessBase, from the World Champion to the amateur next door. Start your personal success story with ChessBase 14 and enjoy your chess even more!


Along with the ChessBase 14 program you can access the Live Database of 8 million games, and receive three months of free ChesssBase Account Premium membership and all of our online apps! Have a look today!

More...

Qatar Masters 2015 Opening dinner

Watch it live on Playchess!

When the games are running, clicking on the above link will take you to our live broadcast. It is free and open to all – as a Premium Account member you have access to the Live Book, Chat, chess engine analysis – all in your browser, on a notebook, tablet or even your smartphone. And the Let's Check function will show you what the most powerful computers in the world think of the current position, as each move is being played. Below are the four most-watched boards.

Note that you can download PGNs of the running games (to analyse with your regular software) and even start an engine in the above broadcast window. The arrow buttons allow you to play through the moves backwards and forwards. The f and g-buttons are self-explanatory.

It was commented from the beginning that the biggest risk top players take upon playing an open such as Qatar is toward their rating. For many top opens, a 2800+ performance is synonymous of a win and reason to cheer, but for someone such as Magnus Carlsen, anything under 2830 means more ratings points lost. Imagine when he was closing in on 2900. Even the best player in the world can learn just how challenging that can be, as he drew IM Nino Batiashvili, who recently scored a GM norm, and helped the Georgian Women team to take Bronze at the ETCC.

The sensation game of the day: World Champion Magnus Carlsen, 2834, vs IM Nino Batsiashvili, 2498

[Event "Qatar Masters Open 2015"] [Site "Doha QAT"] [Date "2015.12.20"] [Round "1.1"] [White "Carlsen, Magnus"] [Black "Batsiashvili, Nino"] [Result "1/2-1/2"] [ECO "A07"] [WhiteElo "2834"] [BlackElo "2498"] [PlyCount "114"] [EventDate "2015.12.20"] 1. Nf3 d5 2. g3 Nf6 3. Bg2 c5 4. c4 d4 5. b4 cxb4 6. a3 b3 7. Qxb3 Nc6 8. O-O e5 9. e3 Be7 10. exd4 exd4 11. Bb2 O-O 12. Re1 Re8 13. a4 Na5 14. Qd3 Be6 15. Na3 Bxa3 16. Bxa3 Bxc4 17. Qxd4 Qxd4 18. Nxd4 Bd5 19. Rxe8+ Rxe8 20. Rc1 b6 21. Bf1 Bb7 22. Nf5 Rd8 23. d4 Nd5 24. Bg2 g6 25. Nd6 Ba8 26. h4 h5 27. Re1 Bc6 28. Re5 Nf6 29. Rxa5 Bxg2 30. Rxa7 Bd5 31. Ra6 Nd7 32. Nb5 Re8 33. Bb4 Re2 34. Ra7 Nf6 35. Kf1 Rb2 36. Bc3 Rc2 37. Rc7 Ng4 38. Ke1 Rxf2 39. Rc8+ Kh7 40. Rd8 Bf3 41. Re8 f6 42. Re7+ Kg8 43. Re8+ Kh7 44. Re7+ Kg8 45. Bd2 Rg2 46. Bf4 g5 47. hxg5 fxg5 48. Bxg5 Rxg3 49. Nc3 Bc6 50. Kd2 Rg2+ 51. Re2 Nf2 52. d5 Bxd5 53. Nxd5 Ne4+ 54. Ke3 Rxe2+ 55. Kxe2 Nxg5 56. Nxb6 Ne6 57. a5 Nc7 1/2-1/2

The cost for drawing a sub-2500 player was around four Elo lost. Obviously a blow for his fans, but it might also serve as the wake-up call he needs to rekindle the embers and take fire.

He was hardly alone though, and while Vladimir Kramnik did win his game in the end...

...he faced some forcing draw lines against Nino’s teammate Bela Khotenashvili

Sadly for Georgian fans, who might have seen the headline “Georgian Women’s team holds Carlsen and Kramnik to a draw.”, Bela failed to find them, and the former world champion went on to outplay her.

Others were less fortunate, such as Dmitry Jakovenko who completely underestimated his 14-year-old Iranian opponent M Amin Tabatabaei, found himself in heaps of trouble and eventually drew an opposite colored bishop ending two pawns down. Still, Iran’s success did not end there, as 12-year-old Alirezja Firouzja defeated GM Pavel Tregubov. This wasn’t the only result for youth, since 11-year-old phenom NodirBek Abdusattorov had no problem holding American GM Sam Shankland to a draw.

Vassily Ivanchuk, a veteran of opens such as Gibraltar, was also held to a draw by 20-year-old IM Ma Zhoghan from China, as was Pentala Harikrishna, India’s no. 2 player, who suffered against his junior compatriot Chithambaram Aravindh and drew. A special mention for ChessBase writer IM Sagar Shah who also drew Vladimir Fedoseev, rated over 220 Elo more.

However, it the upsets did not end with merely some draws. A few notable grandmasters found themselves signing scoresheets with a zero next to their names, about as inauspicious a start as could be. Chinese super-junior Wei Yi was one such notable, as he found himself playing an incredibly inspired IM Shardul Gagare, 18 years old, from India. His win was not by virtue of some unexpected blunder, but rather play that did him credit from end to end. Nikita Vitiugov was another top Elo that fell, as he lost to the unknown IM Xu Yinglun from China, while Denis Khismatullin met a similar fate, losing to the untitled 19-year-old Yuxiang Fang, also from China.

The commentator of the day on Playchess was GM Yasser Seirawan, who did his best to cover all the most conspicuous cases, but with so many games and results, it was a tough job. Be sure to join tomorrow and pitch in the game(s) you feel deserve a closer look.

Full report by IM Sagar Shah to follow...

Pairings/Results of Round 1 on 2015/12/20 at 15:00

Bo. Ti. Name Rtg
Res.
Ti. Name Rtg
1 GM Carlsen Magnus 2834
½-½
IM Batsiashvili Nino 2498
2 GM Khotenashvili Bela 2496
0-1
GM Kramnik Vladimir 2796
3 GM Giri Anish 2784
1-0
IM Sunilduth Narayanan 2494
4 WGM Goryachkina Aleksandra 2493
0-1
GM So Wesley 2775
5 GM Karjakin Sergey 2766
1-0
IM Ezat Mohamed 2490
6 GM Shoker Samy 2489
0-1
GM Li Chao B 2750
7 GM Mamedyarov Shakhriyar 2748
1-0
GM Zhukova Natalia 2488
8 IM Sanal Vahap 2487
0-1
GM Tomashevsky Evgeny 2744
9 GM Harikrishna P. 2743
½-½
GM Aravindh Chithambaram 2486
10 IM Tabatabaei M.Amin 2482
½-½
GM Jakovenko Dmitry 2737
11 GM Yu Yangyi 2736
1-0
GM Neelotpal Das 2475
12 IM Gagare Shardul 2470
1-0
GM Wei Yi 2730
13 GM Vitiugov Nikita 2724
0-1
  Xu Yinglun 2470
14 GM Krush Irina 2468
0-1
GM Wojtaszek Radoslaw 2723
15 GM Korobov Anton 2713
1-0
FM Moroni Luca Jr 2466
16 IM Ma Zhonghan 2463
½-½
GM Ivanchuk Vassily 2710
17 GM Ponomariov Ruslan 2710
1-0
IM Ly Moulthun 2462
18 IM Ali Marandi Cemil Can 2454
½-½
GM Ni Hua 2693
19 GM Moiseenko Alexander 2689
½-½
IM Lorparizangeneh Shahin 2454
20 GM Venkatesh M.R. 2451
0-1
GM Howell David W L 2688
21 GM Matlakov Maxim 2684
1-0
IM Kashlinskaya Alina 2448
22 IM Firat Burak 2446
0-1
GM Hou Yifan 2683
23 GM Adhiban B. 2669
½-½
IM Puranik Abhimanyu 2442
24 IM Sagar Shah 2441
½-½
GM Fedoseev Vladimir 2664
25 GM Duda Jan-Krzysztof 2663
1-0
IM Vogel Roven 2439
26 IM Wang Yiye 2438
0-1
GM Dubov Daniil 2655
27 GM Bologan Viktor 2654
1-0
FM Basso Pier Luigi 2438
28   Fang Yuxiang 2438
1-0
GM Khismatullin Denis 2654
29 GM Akopian Vladimir 2648
½-½
IM Padmini Rout 2437
30 IM Aryan Chopra 2436
0-1
GM Ganguly Surya Shekhar 2648
31 GM Khairullin Ildar 2647
½-½
GM Carlsson Pontus 2433
32 FM Abdusattorov Nodirbek 2429
½-½
GM Shankland Samuel L 2646
33 GM Sjugirov Sanan 2646
1-0
FM Rohan Ahuja 2426
34 IM Nezad Husein Aziz 2425
0-1
GM Swiercz Dariusz 2646
35 GM Vidit Santosh Gujrathi 2644
1-0
IM Seyb Alexander 2425
36 IM Vignesh N R 2422
½-½
GM Nguyen Ngoc TS 2642
37 GM Sethuraman S.P. 2639
1-0
FM Gholami Aryan 2422
38 FM Haria Ravi 2416
½-½
GM Sasikiran Krishnan 2638
39 GM Piorun Kacper 2637
1-0
  Mohammad Nubairshah 2414
40 WGM Saduakassova Dinara 2407
0-1
GM Grandelius Nils 2632
41 GM Naroditsky Daniel 2628
1-0
  Siva Mahadevan 2400
42 IM Saiyn Zhanat 2394
½-½
GM Lenderman Aleksandr 2626
43 GM Salem A.R. Saleh 2622
1-0
IM Abhishek Kelkar 2393
44 WGM Abdumalik Zhansaya 2390
½-½
GM Bartel Mateusz 2620
45 GM Ipatov Alexander 2619
1-0
FM Li Di 2389
46 IM Slavin Alexey 2388
0-1
GM Zhang Zhong 2619
47 GM Lu Shanglei 2618
½-½
IM Christiansen J-S 2385
48 IM Khademalsharieh Saras. 2380
½-½
GM Hamdouchi Hicham 2597
49 GM Vocaturo Daniele 2597
½-½
IM Karavade Eesha 2379
50 IM Konguvel Ponnuswamy 2377
0-1
GM Bok Benjamin 2594
51 GM Bluebaum Matthias 2590
1-0
IM Li Ruofan 2372
52   Firouzja Alireza 2372
1-0
GM Tregubov Pavel V. 2589
53 GM Esen Baris 2562
½-½
  Roy Prantik 2370
54 IM Guramishvili Sopiko 2368
0-1
GM Rambaldi Francesco 2560
55 GM Dzagnidze Nana 2559
0-1
IM Tissir Mohamed 2346
56 WIM Bivol Alina 2344
0-1
GM Kosteniuk Alexandra 2542
57 IM Lin Chen 2532
1-0
  Dai Changren 2328
58   Raja Harshit 2325
1-0
IM Svane Rasmus 2529
59 GM Xu Jun 2526
½-½
WGM Pourkashiyan Atousa 2322
60 IM Pham Le Thao Nguyen 2319
½-½
GM Bromberger Stefan 2521
61 GM Stefanova Antoaneta 2521
1-0
FM Goriatchkin Jouri 2318
62 WFM Vaishali R 2313
0-1
GM Al-Sayed Mohammed 2520
63 GM Harika Dronavalli 2513
1-0
WIM Derakhshani Dorsa 2307
64 IM Piasetski Leon 2287
0-1
GM Sundararajan Kidambi 2513
65 GM Schroeder Jan-Christian 2511
½-½
WGM Bartel Marta 2271
66 WIM Pratyusha Bodda 2260
0-1
IM Yuffa Daniil 2504

Schedule for Playchess Commentary

Day Round Time English German
Sun 20 December  Round 1 3 PM Yasser Seirawan Sebastian Siebrecht
Mon 21 December  Round 2 3 PM Daniel King Sebastian Siebrecht
Tue 22 December  Round 3 3 PM Simon Williams Sebastian Siebrecht
Wed 23 December  Round 4 3 PM Daniel King Thomas Luther
Thu 24 December  Round 5 3 PM Simon Williams Thomas Luther
Fri 25 December  Rest day      
Sat 26 December  Round 6 3 PM Mihail Marin Thomas Luther
Sun 27 December  Round 7 3 PM Simon Williams Sebastian Siebrecht
Mon 28 December  Round 8 3 PM Daniel King Sebastian Siebrecht
Tue 29 December  Round 9 12 PM Yasser Seirawan Sebastian Siebrecht

Photos by Alla Oborina for the official web site


Links

The games will be broadcast live on the official web site and on the server Playchess.com. If you are not a member you can download a free Playchess client there and get immediate access. You can also use ChessBase or any of our Fritz compatible chess programs.
 


Born in the US, he grew up in Paris, France, where he completed his Baccalaureat, and after college moved to Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. He had a peak rating of 2240 FIDE, and was a key designer of Chess Assistant 6. In 2010 he joined the ChessBase family as an editor and writer at ChessBase News. He is also a passionate photographer with work appearing in numerous publications.
Discussion and Feedback Join the public discussion or submit your feedback to the editors


Discuss

Rules for reader comments

 
 

Not registered yet? Register

Peter B Peter B 12/22/2015 02:56
dhochee: according to chessgames.com the Vila Rodriguez draw was in a rapid event.
dhochee dhochee 12/21/2015 09:07
To answer flachspieler's question, Magnus drew with Vila Rodriguez (2437) on 2014-07-03. That's the most recent I could find but my database is a few months old.
indera indera 12/21/2015 11:23
2500 rated player still a strong opponent for any top GM. Lot of top GMs playing on closed selected tournament, thus making them had tough game against unfamiliar name. Against top GM, they easily remember all the lines, but against unknown, they have to think more over the board move.
flachspieler flachspieler 12/21/2015 10:33
Before this event: when was the last time Carlsen did not win against an opponent with reating below 2500?
thlai80 thlai80 12/21/2015 03:42
Considering Kasparov was known to beat the whole national teams (Germany, Czech for example) in simul with average rating close to 2600+, then world champion and world #1 drawing someone who is below 2500 ELO is an absolute upset. Ask Magnus himself, I'm sure he would said it is a total disgrace.
karavamudan karavamudan 12/21/2015 03:38
Folks stop going after Carlsen. If you can, try beating him over the chessboard. His style of play has less % of wins, but those wins really matter despite the odd loss or many draws.
imdvb_8793 imdvb_8793 12/21/2015 03:15
Yeah, but, actually, based on the ELO tables (which are, in turn, based on very concrete and well thought out statistical analysis of chess results over long periods of time), a player rated 336 points higher than his opponent (as Carlsen was) is expected to score 88% out of any number of games against said opponent, so, basically, the lower rated player is, in this case, supposed to get a draw about once every five games (or two draws/a win once every 10 games, but losing all of the others) - and I've only used the fact that Carlsen had white to round things out A LITTLE BIT, though that's probably a much bigger advantage than the 2% I rounded down. So, no, a player rated 2500 is, in fact, NOT expected to get a LARGE number of draws against a 2800+ player (for 300 points, the percentages are similar, 85-15 percent), but a very SMALL number of draws. This draw was, (crudely) statistically speaking, about 20% likely to happen, which I think qualifies it as not only an upset, but a pretty big upset. Maybe you think getting beaten 4.5-0.5 or 9-1 by a player only 300 points higher rated is a good result, but I'm sure most would agree with me that it's just not.
Bertman Bertman 12/21/2015 12:28
Your definition of the term "upset" does not agree with that of dictionaries or other.
Aighearach Aighearach 12/20/2015 11:11
I'm not sure about this "upset." A player rated ~2500 is expected to get a large number of draws against a player 2800+.

A 2800+ is not expected to win 100% of the games, and yet this sort of concept of draw-as-upset rounds everything off and creates logical errors. If you're willing to round off all the way to expecting only wins and losses, then if a player rated merely 2800 gets a draw against Carlsen, that is also an upset.

As a player, it doesn't matter what people call it, it scores the same. As a fan, it seems more reasonable to talk only about wins as upsets unless it is a youth player or there is over 400 points of difference. At the class level, you need at least a full class for it to be considered an "upset." If you're tracking "upset points" for a prize then any difference scores, but in general conversation the difference has be 200 points because that is the size of the rating classes. A draw scores only 50%, and that is also true for upset points. But for it to be "an upset" I would then expect the rating difference to be _at_least_ double the difference needed for a win to be an upset.

So Carlsen would need to be 2900 for a draw against a 2500 to be an upset, in my analysis. He might get there yet, but not in this tourney!
1