Federation Internationale Des Echecs
Mr. President Kirsan Ilyumzhinov / Presidential board
Oslo, fredag, 3. mai 2013
Dear Mr. Ilyumzhinov / Presidential board
With reference to the discussion that for some time has been going on between FIDE and Magnus Carlsen’s representatives with regard to the venue for the upcoming FIDE World Championship Match, the Norwegian Chess Federation finds reasons to intervene in this dialogue with a formal letter to FIDE.
As you are aware of Mr. Magnus Carlsen has expressed dissatisfaction with the plans to arrange the World Championship Match in Chennai, India without having any formal competition on the venue for this match. Mr. Carlsen’s view has been presented to FIDE both in emails and in a meeting in Athens with his manager and his lawyer.
It is our understanding of the rules and regulations for the FIDE World Championship Match 2013 that any federation or sponsor may bid for being an organizer. We strongly urge FIDE to facilitate a procedure that enables other interested parties to bid for the event. Furthermore FIDE must, based on the regulation consider all bids before making a final decision. From the regulations, it is not clear that FIDE has the right to grant Chennai an option.
We maintain, as expressed by Mr. Carlsen, that it will be an advantage both for the players and FIDE to have a fair and transparent procedure and competition for the selection of the organizer and also for the reputation of chess in general.
Since the Championship is to be held in November, there will be acceptable time to consider other bids and make a qualified decision in due time prior to the event.
The Norwegian Chess Federation expects that FIDE will follow its own regulation for the World Championship Match enabling others to bid for the event as was the procedure for selection of the organizer for the 2014 Chess Olympiad.
We would like to emphasize that this is not a campaign against Chennai as an organizer; it is merely a request to follow the rules and principles of transparency and fairness.
This letter should be regarded as formal complaint on the process for selecting
the organizer for the
World Championship Match 2013.
Photo: VG Nett
"Norway sends complaint about Carlsen
match" reads the headline
of the above article (click to read, if you can handle Norwegian)
We now hear the paris is ready to organize the 2013 Anand-Carlsen World Chess Championship match. We received the following communication just hours after the above letter from the Norwegian Chess Federation:
Paris – 3rd of May 2013. The city of Paris, France, is ready to host the World Chess Championship Match between GM Viswanathan Anand, from India, and GM Magnus Carlsen, from Norway.
In a letter to FIDE, the Mayor of Paris Mr. Bertrand Delanoë, expresses full support to the French Chess Federation in its aim to organize the final match to take place in November 2013.
The Paris Mayor states in his letter to FIDE that “the city of Paris welcomes the French Chess Federation initiative” to organize the Anand-Carlsen Chess World Championship, and “is happy to give its whole hearted support to the French Chess Federation to successfully carry out this project.”
The offer sent to FIDE includes a €2.65 million prize fund and a €800,000 contribution to FIDE in accordance to FIDE regulations. It also offers a specific budget allocated for media coverage.
“Paris is the city where FIDE was born and ever since, chess has been part of our cultural heritage. Our Capital is looking forward to organize and welcome in the best possible conditions this Championship” concludes Mayor Delanoë’s letter to FIDE President Kirsan Ilymzhinov.
FIDE, the World Chess Federation, was founded in Paris in 1924. A world Chess Championship in Paris would be a prelude to FIDE’s 90th anniversary.
WWC in Paris
Note that the budget for the Chennai bid was US $3,376,250 = €2,576,280, with a prize fund of US $2.55 million = €1.94 million. This, according to our calculations, means that Paris is offering €710,000 (= $931,000) more in prize money and an around €870,000 (= $1.14 million) higher overall budget than Chennai.
Attached to Philippe Mouttou message was the following letter by the Mayor of Paris to the President of FIDE:
Click to enlarge. The following official translation was included
Dear Mr President,
I have learnt with great interest of the French Chess Federation project to organize in Paris the upcoming Chess World Championship in later in November this year. This Championship is very exciting with the match between Viswanathan Anand and Magnus Carlsen.
The city of Paris welcomes this initiative and I am happy to give my whole hearted support to the French Chess Federation to successfully carry out this project.
Paris is the city where FIDE was born and ever since, chess has been part of our cultural heritage. Our Capital is looking forward to organize and welcome in the best possible conditions this Championship that will enable Paris to profile itself internationally.
Monsieur Kirsan ILYUMZHINOV
President de la Federation Intemationale d'Echecs
9 Syggrou avenue
11743 ATHENES GREECE