Opinion
poll by ChessBase and ACP
amongst top players
By Olena Boytsun, ACP Board Member
In November 2008 FIDE announced major changes to the World Championship cycle.
This resulted in a huge wave of discussions: Alexei Shirov and Levon
Aronian publicly questioning the legality and consistency of the abrupt
changes to a running cycle, which Magnus Carlsen and Michael
Adams withdrew from the Grand Prix qualifier 2008-2009.
During a press conference in Elista in December 2009 FIDE President Kirsan
Ilyumzhinov stated that a final decision on the changes in the current cycle
will be taken in March 2009 at the Presidential Board meeting, and that he will
take into the consideration the opinions expressed during the online meeting
with the chess players.
In December the Association of Chess Professionals put out a statement
recommending that “FIDE should build a sustainable dialog with chess players,
where the ACP could play a role of mediator. Consultation and discussion are
the key words to lay the foundations for a fair World Chess Championship cycle.”
On December 27th 2008 FIDE conducted a telephone conference with five players
and five officials. Members of the ACP Board were, however, not invited to take
part, nor were many other chess players directly involved in the World Championship
cycle. The results of the meeting as well as a transcript of the conference
have not been made available as of 12.02.2009.
Since this meeting was restricted to five players and has not been adequately
documented, the Association of Chess Professionals and ChessBase have decided
to conduct a survey amongst a larger number of top players, i.e. all those who
are theoretically involved in the World Championship Cycle. The results of this
poll will be presented to FIDE before the Presidential Board meeting in March
2009.
The main aim of the ACP-ChessBase questionnaire is to understand the opinion
of top chess players on the most important issues of their professional life.
The poll will be conducted by email in order to make sure that the answers are
genuinely from the players surveyed. The criteria of the participation are as
follows: players with a rating above 2690 (on the January 2009 FIDE list), plus
the participants of the current cycle, plus some ex-world champions.
The questionnaire will be sent to the respondents on the 13th of February 2009.
We expect to receive the replies and evaluate them in a 2-3 week period. The
results should be made public on ChessBase.com and the ACP web site in the first
week of March 2009.
The ACP Board
February 12, 2008
Questionnaire
Note that this questionnaire is being published here for the information
of players and the general chess public. It should not be used to answer the
questions. Players who are part of our poll will be contacted directly, within
the next few days, by email, with a copy of the questions. It is only by answering
this email that you participate in the poll.
1. What in your opinion is the best format for a World Championship final?
a. A match
b. A round robin or double round robin tournament
c. A knock-out tournament
d. Another form (please specify precisely what)
2. What is the best qualification system for the World Championship final?
a. Candidates matches
b. A round robin tournament
c. A knock-out tournament
d. Another form (please specify precisely what)
3. What time controls should be used in World Championship events?
a. The so called "Classical" time controls (6-7 hour per game)
b. The so called "FIDE" time controls (3-5 hours per game)
c. The so called "rapid" time controls (approx. one hour per game)
d. Any other (please specify precisely what)
4. What time controls should be used for chess tournaments in general?
a. The so called "Classical" time controls (6-7 hour per game)
b. The so called "FIDE" time controls (90 min for 40 moves, then
30 min for the rest, + 30 sec/move from move 1)
c. The so called "rapid" time controls (approx. one hour per game)
d. Any other (please specify precisely what)
5. What do you think about a time increment after each move?
a. I think there should be an increment from move 1
b. I think there should be an increment from move 40
c. I am against any form of increment
d. It depends on the time control (please specify precisely how)
6. What is your opinion about dress code during World Championships and top
tournaments?
a. Suit and tie should be obligatory
b. "Decent dress" obligatory (for instance jacket, no sport shoes)
c. I don’t see a necessity, but would accept it
d. I am against any dress code
7. What do you think about doping control?
a. It should be obligatory and comply with the regulations of the IOC
b. I would accept doping control if it is adapted specifically for chess
c. I don’t see a necessity for doping controls, but would accept it
d. I am against any doping controls
8. What do you think about anti-computer cheating controls?
a. They should be obligatory and made as tough as possible
b. Obligatory, but only metal detectors and light controls
c. I don’t see a necessity, but would accept it
d. I am against any such controls
9. What do you think the punishment for being late for a game should be?
a. The player automatically forfeits the game
b. A financial or rating penalty
c. Any other (please specify precisely what)
d. There should not be any penalty
10. What do you think about the current rating system?
a. It is fine, no changes needed
b. I would make changes (please specify precisely which)
11. What do you think about changes made to the current WCC cycle (change of
format, etc.)?
a. I object to any changes made to the current cycle
b. I accept the changes to the current cycle, if they lead to increasing
of the overall prize fund of the cycle
c. I accept any changes made to the current cycle
d. Other: (please specify)
12. What do you think about staging Super-GM tournaments in a soundproof glass
cabin in a public square, as was done in Bilbao 2008?
a. I think it is a good idea and I am comfortable with it
b. I am uncomfortable with it, but I accept it because it benefits chess.
c. I reject the idea because… (please specify)
Other proposals
If you have other comments or suggestions please add them to your answer at
the bottom.
Name: ______________________________________ Date: _______________________
Some instructions regarding your submissions:
- We will be sending you the questionnaire as a Word and as a plain text file.
You can use either to submit your answer.
- Please leave each question in place and delete the answers you reject, keeping
only the one that reflects your opinion.
- You can add remarks to each question, even if you choose one of the answers
given.
- Please send your replies by email to the address given in the message.
If you are a 2690+ player or in any way a participant in the World Championship
cycle, and you do not receive the questionnaire by the 15th of February, please
contact Olena Boytsun
with your correct email details.
Copyright ChessBase
and ACP
