Open
Letter to Chess Players and Media
"Another day for you and me in Paradise" - Phil Collins
Wednesday, June 11, 2003
Dear journalists and chess players,
Following the publication of the open letter by some of the participants in
the European Individual Chess Championships in Silivri, Turkey, we would like
to clarify some accusations, remarks and points made by the participants who
signed this letter.
1. The Turkish Chess Federation (TCF) secured the organization of both men
and women tournaments through a transparent bidding process in the European
Chess Union (ECU). All conditions were clearly stipulated and agreed upon during
the last ECU General Assembly. The TCF even filled a gap when the original bidding
Federation withdrew its offer. All players who came to Silivri or were sent
by their Federations, were aware at the outset about these conditions. It is
very strange therefore that some players are claiming unfair conditions since
these were publicly announced quite well in advance.
2. The TCF has increased the prize fund to a record $192,000 for the men's
tournament and $44,000 for the women's tournament which is the highest ever
in the history of the ECU. As players are highly aware, sponsors do not grow
on trees and one key condition of the sponsor was that the tournament should
be held in the Hotel Princess in Silivri. Whilst some players have requested
that they be free to chose the hotel they would like to stay in the future,
this would only impact on the eventual prize money which would be awarded.
3. A claim has been made that some Russian tourists pay $35 per night full
board. Despite the assurance of the general manager that this is impossible,
the claim was still made without any proof being provided! In fact a verbal
retraction was made by one of the players, which was not amended also in their
open letter, since there is now an admission by this player that the rate quoted
was for half board and that there are some other costs….
4. The quality of organisation in this tournament cannot be compared with the
quality of previous tournaments. TCF has participated in these tournaments and
has first hand experience of the conditions offered then. We have offered during
these two tournaments:
- five star hotel rooms
- open buffet (reallly open buffet!!) meals.
- excellent hotel facilities, pools, sauna, fitness rooms etc…
- free coffee/tea service during the tournament (approximately every day 2,500
cups of tea or coffee are consumed!)
- outstandingly excellent carpeted playing halls (around 3,000 square metres)
as you have seen in the regular photos on the organization web site
- free internet browsing facilities with 35 network points provided for the
players
- free bulletins posted nightly after each round
- 24 hour doctor available on call for the players and free medicine (cost
to organiser)
- top ten games of each tournament transmitted live over the internet daily
- highest ever prize fund!
5. Another misleading issue is the rates which were quoted. In the case of
Warsaw 2001, the rate quoted is for a double room. The single room rate was
$60. It was also conevenient to leave out a very little point. The exchange
rate in May 2001 for an ECU was 1$= 1.1274€ (this data is available widely
on the web and can be easily confirmed) whilst the rate as at today is 1$ =
0.8568€. A basic calculation shows that the rate for Warsaw was therefore
67.6€ whilst in Silivri it works out at 68.54€. Quite a difference!
6. Other interesting points conveniently left out are that the prize money
in Ohrid was subject to 15% tax charge whereas the TCF has managed to obtain
this year's prizes tax-free.
7. As the host organiser the TCF does not 'do whatever we want'. This is a
completely unfair comment since their Federations ultimately represent these
players and whilst constructive comments are appreciated there is no recommendation
at any point in the letter to, say, reduce the prize fund by around $50,000
and consequently reduce the demands on sponsors. The National Federations are
directly the members of the ECU and the players are represented by their Federation.
There is a forum to discuss these issues in a professional manner. Chess is
a respectable sport and we expect the players to act in fair and ethical ways.
8. The majority of signatories on the letter have all their expenses covered
by their own National Federation. Any claims about costs should be made by the
National Federations themselves, and the motive behind the players' claims in
these cases is not understandable.
9. A number of players have apologized in writing to both the ECU President
and the TCF that they had not been informed correctly of the contents of the
letter and they do not agree with the points of the open letter. We will provide
copies of these letters if requested.
10. Regarding the prize fund for the woman's tournament, the TCF has always
declared in advance that the prize money for Silivri would work out at $35,000
(TCF contribution) plus FIDE's contribution of $20,000 less the 20% for ECU
and FIDE charges.
11. TCF is one of the only organizers who had declared their tournament budget
and costs. The tournament is the strongest ever in the history of ECU chess
and this is thanks to the prize fund. We did not try and cut corners since we
must try and do everything in the best professional way. The chess world is
currently going through some difficult times to find sponsors and all people
should work together to achieve the best results.
Some
players have understood the situation and thanked the TCF for the hospitality
and quality of organisation. We will be guided by discussions in the future
within ECU and recommendations by players are always welcome. However we feel
that our reply is honest and fair, as we have always tried to be and that the
chess world benefits from such prestigious events.
Ali Nihat Yazici
President - Turkish Chess Federation
